Protocolz Menu
|
WHEN VICTIMS
RULE,
A Critique of Jewish Pre-eminence in America
Source: JTR
Website
20.
* Note: Positions
of power and ownership are
always in flux. Companies
are bought and sold these
days with extraordinary
frequency and career rungs
change quickly. The facts
noted in the next chapters
for those of current power
should be regarded as an
overall pattern and not
an absolute freeze point
for any individual and his/her
controlling interests. Such
facts are also merely a
general sampling, and may
be regarded -- in overview
-- as the proverbial "tip
of an iceberg."
In the
following chapters, too,
many people are identified
as being of Jewish heritage
as part of this investigation
of Jewish power in America.
Often Jewish journals and
scholars identify them.
Sometimes too, when the
subject is portrayed in
a good, or at least neutral,
light, they are identified
as such in the popular mass
media. When Jews make the
news for being in trouble
with the law, they are more
often freely identified
as Jews in the British press
than in the United States.
In America, they are more
likely noted neutrally,
as "white," "Russian," "Iranian,"
or other ethnicities under
which Jewish identities
may be subsumed.
Sometimes the Jewish
heritage of the powerful
or newsworthy is difficult
to ascertain, but their
ethnicity can often be decided
via articles about relatives,
relationships to Israel,
synagogues, religious holidays,
cultural indicators, or
Jewish-configured political
organizations and other
tangential leads. Many surnames
(Cohen, Katz, Kaplan, Levy,
Levine, Levin, etc.) are
instantly recognizable to
the informed as Jewish and,
even if a small minority
of individuals with such
names are only "half-Jewish"
or, rarely, converts to
some other religion, the
familial link to the Jewish
community (especially in
homage to the Holocaust
and often modern Israel)
may fairly be presumed to
be no small thing. For purposes
here, that allegiance, and
all it entails, is the crucial
determinant in determining
who is Jewish. The ambiguous
"community of fate" is,
after all, one of the major
self-defined measures of
Jewish identity. This is
particularly true of those
who hold power of some sort
in popular culture: most
of these people are in significant
degree part of a Jewish
network, especially an economic
and political one.
In these
senses, this work follows
the lead of the Jewish community
(and the Jewish ethnic media)
itself. (Many individuals,
however, who may well be
Jewish, had to be left out
of this assemblage because
public information was too
weak and names were too
ambiguous to presume that
they had a Jewish background).
This entire methodology
(ironically ascribed by
Jews as a manifestation
of anti-Semitism if it represents
anything less than an intention
to flatter Jewry) is popular
in the Jewish world itself,
often noted as "nose-counting"
or "bean-counting": usually
a celebratory emphasis of
who exactly is Jewish and/or
its attendant search for
allegiances.
As Jewish scholar
Nathan Glazer has noted
about this phenomena, and
its tinge of paranoia:
"A leading figure in the Jewish community
affairs relates that a
Jew
eagerly asks, in any situation,
'How many are Jews?' And
when
he gets an answer, he asks
suspiciously, 'How do you
know?'" [NEUSNER, J., 1972, p.
3]
Efforts here to determine
specifically who is Jewish
are, in some ways, more
extensive than most Jewish
organizations' demographic
studies themselves. In a
1999 investigation of the
Jews of the Miami area by
the Jewish Federation of
South Palm Beach County,
for example, the way to
ascertain who was Jewish
was simple. Ten percent
of common Jewish names were
merely tallied, and compared
to other years, from phone
books. From this base, estimates
were made. This method of
determining Jewish population
numbers "has been used by
Jewish demographers across
the country for 40 years."
[BELKIN, D., 5-6-99, p.
B1] An American Jewish Committee
examination of voter patterns
in the Philadelphia was
in large part "based on
surnames gathered from voter-registration
records." [FELDMAN, S.,
3-2-2000, p. 1] Jewish author
George Gilbert, like many,
notes in his introduction
to his volume about "Jewish
photographers," that "for
the purposes of this study,
individuals are deemed Jewish
even if they do not meet
the halakhic structure responsible
for traditional Jewish religious
criteria: being born of
a Jewish mother." [GILBERT,
G., 1996, p. ix] Stanley
Rothman's and S. Robert
Lichter's definition of
Jewry to qualify for inclusion
in a book about Jewish political
radicalism goes like this:
"We classified students
as Jewish if the ethnic
background of both parents
was Jewish, or if only one
parent was of Jewish background
but had raised the child
as a Jew or without religious
training." [ROTHMAN/LICHTER,
1982, p. 213] In 1973 Harry
Golden noted United Jewish
Appeal methodologies to
find the Jewish nouveau
riche to pester for philanthropic
donations: "[UJA] researchers
go over every prospectus
issued by the Securities
and Exchange Commission,
attentively study advertised
stock offerings in every
city, and plow through hundreds
of year-end reports to the
stockholders issued by major
industries, always on the
lookout for that Jewish
name that they have never
read before." Another UJA
division scans obituaries,
looking for affluent Jews
by surname, intent upon
contacting survivors. [GOLDEN,
H., 1973, p. 119] No apologies are thereby made for such
popular Jewish research
methodologies that are in
large part followed here.
"Having money is a good thing, having power
over money is
-- Old Yiddish folk saying [KUMOVE,
S., 1985, p. 16]
Old Yiddish folk saying,
[KUMOVE, S., 1985, p. 179]
"The rich breed more rich."
Old Yiddish folk saying,
[KUMOVE, S., 1985, p. 251]
"The rich man's way is without
fair play."
-- Old Yiddish folk saying, [KUMOVE, S.,
1985, p. 251]
"Villains fare well in this
world, saints in the next
world."
-- Old Yiddish folk saying, [KUMOVE, S.,
1985, p. 84]
"Behind every fortune lies a crime." --
Balzac
"Jewish money," noted
Gerald Krefetz, "-- its
purported influence and
power-- is one of the oldest
canards of anti-Semitism.
Therefore, the topic is
usually dealt with in the
softest of voices by Jews
for fear of raising the
specter of anti-Semitism;
and by non-Jews for fear
of being tarred by the brush,
of being called anti-Semites
for even ventilating the
subject. The omission is
startling since money --
its use and abuse, its acquisition
and disposition -- was and
is a central element in
the Jewish experience."
[KREFETZ, p. 3]
As
an Eastern European Jewish
fable notes about the subject
of anti-Jewish hostility,
traditional tension between
Jewish haves and
Gentile have-nots,
and the wisdom of keeping
relative Jewish affluence
hidden:
"Once
the good-hearted rabbi of
Chelm was interrupted in
his devotions
by the sudden appearance
of one of his townspeople,
Yankele, bleeding
and howling in pain. The
shabbes-goy [non-Jewish
Saturday servant for
Jews] had gratuitously punched
Yankele in the mouth. The
rabbi asked
solicitously if he could
inspect the damage. But
when Yankele opened
his mouth, the rabbi was
horriifed. How does a Jew
come to have such
a healthy set of teeth?
Are these the very teeth
that Yankele had exposed
to the shabbes-goy?
Well, then, no wonder he
had been brutalized.
For a Jew to show such strong
tetth is in itself a provocation.
The
rabbi counseled Yankele
never to show his teeth
to any Gentile again.
In
susequent weeks, although
Yankele keeps his mouth
dutifully shut, the
shabbes-goy beats
him up repeatedly. Each
time the rabbi, after due
analysis of the situation,
discovers a provocation:
once Yankele had carried
a loaf of bread home from
the marketplace, obviously
attracting the shabbes-goy's
envy;
a second time he had strayed
too far out of town, obviously
transgressing what
the shabbes-goy considered
to be the Jew's legitimate
bounds. Finally,
after
still another beating, the
rabbi realizes the gravity
of the situation and
calls
a public meeting of the
local Jewish elders to resolve
the matter. The
meeting unanimously concludes
that Yankele is too dangerous
to keep in town.
At the rabbi's suggestion
he if forced to leave, and
the shabbes-goy's
wages
are modestly raised to placate
him and 'move him to pity.'"
[SHORRIS, E.,
1982, p. 98-99; written
by WISSE, RUTH]
"Jewish success in
America," says Henry Feingold,
"appears to rest partly
on the pre-existing Jewish
culture (which gives it
behavioral cues, a unique
entrepreneurial vision,
plus connections and capital);
and American culture (which
gives it a success ethos,
economic opportunity, and
open society)." [FEINGOLD,
p. 41]
"Jews," noted Israeli
scholar Boas Evron in 1995,
"are among the most powerful,
best integrated and wealthy
groups in the United States,
Britain, and France." [EVRON,
p. 48] "Jews," adds Joseph Heckelman, "are
disproportionately visible
in every area of human endeavor.
In other words, Jews are
disproportionately successful."
[HECKELMAN, J., p. 68] "Success
is a basic fact of Jewish
American life," observed
Roger Kahn in 1968, "...
Success surrounds and infuses
their lives. Success in
business; success in educating
children; success in entering
the most hotly-sought endeavors.
Jews are business owners,
business managers, professionals,
writers and artists. Few
are laborers. Virtually
none is a farmhand." [KAHN,
R., p. 4] "We didn't
progress because we were
Jewish," a Jewish factory
owner in Brooklyn told researcher
Jonathan Rider in 1985,
"but because we are a driving,
pushing people." [REIDER,
J., 1985, p. 45]
Karl Marx's
mid-19th century comment
that America had already
become "Judaized" (i.e.,
commercialized and rendered
excessively materialistic)
through Jewish influence
upon America's own stringent
brand of Protestantism,
was echoed in 1911 by the
Jewish anthropologist, Maurice
Fishberg:
"Fifty years ago the
criminology of the Jews
was a good indication of
what modern
society is coming to under
commercial and financial
activity. In
this respect, as was the
case with many other peculiarities,
such as the
excessive number of psychopathics
and neuropathics, the
Jews have only
been the advance agents.
Many publicists of Europe
have, in fact,
often designated conditions
in the United States as
'Jewish.'" [FISHBERG,
p. 549]
"The power of commercialism
in the United States was
hardly to be denied," says
Albert Lindemann, "The English
themselves were often taken
aback by the commercial
scramble in the United States
in the nineteenth century,
by the 'Jewish souls of
the Yankee.'" [LINDEMANN,
p. 206]
"It has been the
Jews," says Edward Shapiro,
"who taught Americans how
to dance (Arthur Murray),
what to wear (Ralph Lauren),
how to behave (Dear Abby
and Ann Landers), and where
to complain (David Horowitz).
[SHAPIRO, Anti-Sem,
p. 1]
Jews even gave the
world the idealized images
of the Barbie doll and Superman.
"If you live in New York
or any other major city,"
said comedian Lenny Bruce,
"you are Jewish." [RUBIN,
p. 89]
As
Chaim Bermant notes:
"There is probably less anti-semitism and certainly less overt
anti-semitism in
the world today than at
any other time since the
rise of Christianity. Auschwitz
is,
of course, one reason; another
is the decline in religious
fanaticism and, indeed,
in
religious belief in general,
and while rampant secularism
may be a threat to Judaism
it has made life easier
for the Jew. A third reason,
which is connected to the
second,
is
that the western world has
become more Jewish. The
commerical drive which
was said to characterize
the Jew and which was regarded
with such disdain by the
European (if not the American)
bourgeoisie, has become,
if not respectable, then
at
least more widespread and
acceptable ..." [BERMANT,
C., 1977, p. 37]
"If the religious
traditions of the shtetl
had accustomed Jews
to think of luxuries as
a type of instrument for
dignifying the holy days,"
says Andrew Heinze, "the
secular American environment
refocused this awareness."
[HEINZE, p. 5] ... By exploiting
the Jewish concept of honoring
a holiday, merchants and
consumers turned the religious
occasion into a pretext
for shopping ... [HEINZE,
p. 66] ... As a pretext
for shopping, Jewish holidays
merged subtly with the fashion
cycle." [HEINZE, p. 67] "The turn of the century New York Yiddish
press," writes Paula Hyman
and Deborah Moore, "abounded
with references to the enthusiasm
of Jewish women, even the
newly arrived, for the latest
style of dress and interior
decoration. Furthermore,
there were certain clear
contrasts between Jews and
other groups in respect
to the consumption of goods
... [Jewish] attraction
to new kinds of products
and pleasures also contributed
to the rapid development
of a resort culture among
Jews, which set them apart
not only from other immigrants,
but from virtually all Americans
of similar modest means."
[HYMAN, p. 24] Among the best known of these
resorts in the Catskill
Mountains was Grossinger's.
"In the 1860s and
1870s," notes William Leach,
"luxury was seen by many
Americans as morally corrupting
... By the 1920s, luxury
seems to have lost for many
people much of its negative
meaning." [LEACH, p. 295]
"The modern definition of
luxury," decided an influential
Columbia University economist,
Edwin R. Seligman, in 1927,
"is neutral so far as ethical
connotation is concerned."
[LEACH, p. 295]
"Nourished by American
conditions and values,"
says Andrew Heinze, "Jewish
merchants were able to make
a profound impact in the
era before World War I.
In the areas of street marketing
and film marketing, they
would completely change
the prevalent mode of operations,
thereby demonstrating that
Jewish adaptation in America
entailed the creation as
well as the reception of
new forms of consumption."
[HEINZE, p. 181-182]
"The contemporary
historian John Higham,"
notes Edward Shapiro, "has
concluded that the Jewish
emphasis on the materialistic
and competitive values of
business is also 'deeply
ingrained in American life.'"
[SHAPIRO, p. 11]
Even modern advertising
and the selling of "brand
names" can be traced to
Jewish origins, particularly
rooted in the Jewish Rothschild
banking monolith in Germany
in the 1800s. The House
of Rothschild, notes Sam
Lehman-Wilzig, "developed
... institutionalized advertising.
Advertising today is taken
for granted as a central
cog in the capitalist system,
especially in regard to
fueling demand. This was
not always the case; for
as [German economist Werner]
Sombart points out, a pretty
display in a window was
considered unethical business
practice a mere three hundred
years ago. Noteworthy is
that this institution was
elevated by HR [the House
of Rothschild] to new heights,
advertising not any specific
product but a corporate
name." [LEHMAN-WILZIG, p.
256]
In a more recent expression
of the "brand name" archetype,
Christopher Byron traces
the Israeli Nakash brothers
(of Jordache
jeans) road to success
in America in the 1980s:
"Steeped in the Middle
Eastern arts of obliqueness
and guile, the
brothers seemed manipulative
by nature. And as the youngest
of the
three, Avi's guile
certainly showed through
when he came up with a
gimmick that would
make them all rich. Catching
on quickly to the
American way of doing
things, he suggested that
they forget about
the product and invest
in the image instead. In
other words, spend
the money on an ad
campaign ... And what more
mesmerized the
masses than sex, wealth,
and social power ... If
a four-dollar swatch
of denim could be
turned into a symbol of
success, there was just
no telling how much
people would be willing
to pay for it ... [The
first TV commercial
they personally created]
the three networks
all rejected ... as lewd, but New York area independents
agreed to
carry it, and within
weeks Jordache
was the rage of every
high
school in the Greater
New York area." [BYRON,
p. 34-35]
Another example of
the artificial construct
of economic value is the
entire world of diamonds,
largely controlled internationally
by Jews. The idea of an
"engagement ring" (and specifically
a diamond one, as an expression
of eternal love) is a recent
phenomena, created by advertising
agencies to sell more diamonds.
David Koskoff notes that:
"Harry
Oppenheimer [the head of
the South African-based
De Beers
diamond
syndicate] is usually credited
with augmenting demand [for
diamonds]
through advertising, which
De Beers undertook in 1939 ...
Most
diamantaries [those in the
diamond trade] appreciate
that the value
of
their product is illusory
and dependent on the props
maintained by
De Beers." [KOSKOFF, The Diamonds,
p. 272
In 1993 the Israeli
author Amos Oz paraphrased
a Jewish critic's referral
to the special Jewish entrepreneurial
vision:
"We Israelis hear
now and then that the very
state of Israel might
have been a mistake
... George Steiner goes
even further by adding
that a national state
per se is vain, childish,
anachronistic, and a
dangerous concept.
We should aspire to 'Judaifying'
the entire world
by turning it into
the arena of one hundred
different civilizations,
rather than a single
nation state." [OZ, p. 117]
"Western civilization,"
says Albert Lindemann, "is
undeniably a 'jewified'
civilization, however offensive
the word may be to our ears
because of the ugly use
made of it by anti-Semites
... Anti-Semites believed
that Jews were everywhere,
and in a sense they were
almost everywhere that counted
in modern society." [LINDEMANN,
Esau's, p. 20]
WASP
economic and social dominance
in America was well along
in the process of being
dismantled when Jewish commentator
Peter Schrag wrote in 1971
that
"In the
last twenty-five years,
dissecting the establishment
has become a
highly
popular academic endeavor.
C. Wright Mills (among others)
took
it on in The Power Elite,
E. Digby Baltzell in The
Protestant
Establishment,
G. William Domhoff in The
Higher Circles and Who
Rules
America? One might suspect
that the very existence
of these
studies
indicates that the subject
bears more resemblance to
a carcass
than
to a living body." [SCHRAG,
p. 161]
******************************************
The first
immigration group of Jews
to America came in the colonial
era; they were largely Sephardic
and established themselves
as a merchant elite. "They
were "among the founders
of such Establishment institutions
as the New York Stock Exchange,
Columbia University, New
York University, the American
Medical Association, and
the Boston Atheneum." [ZWEIGANHAFT,
p. 9] Hayman Levy was the largest fur trader
in colonial America; even
Daniel Boone was hired by
a Jew, "Jacob Cohen, and
other Jewish merchants to
survey the land, mark out
roads and locate land claims
in Kentucky." [DAVIS, D.,
129] A second immigrant
group arrived in the middle
of the 19th century; some
of these "made their way
into investment banking,
where they were joined by
an equally successful group
of Jews stemming from the
banking houses established
by the Jews in Germany."
[FEINGOLD, p. 39]
By the 1870s, "proportionally
speaking, in no other immigrant
group have so many ever
risen so rapidly from rags
to riches." [ZWEIGENHAFT,
p. 11] "The first generation
of [Jewish] millionaires
included the manufacturer
Philip Heidelbach, the bankers
Josephs Seligman, Lewis
Seasongood, and Solomon
Loeb, the railroad magnates
Emanuel and Mayer Lehman,
and a good many more. The
generall body of American
Jews participated in the
same upward thrust; a survey
of 10,000 Jewish families
in 1890 showed that 7,000
of them had servants." [HIGHAM,
J., 1957, p. 8] "Many Jews,"
noted Richard Zweigenhaft
and G. William Domhoff,
"were influential in founding
the very clubs that helped
set the upper class apart
from the rest of society
... Like the Sephardim who
preceded them, the wealthiest
German Jews were accepted
in the most prestigious
social clubs, and many interacted
with and were entertained
socially by 'the best' of
gentile society." [ZWEIGENHAFT,
p. 10] In 1889 62% of American
Jews in the occupational
world were either bankers,
brokers, wholesalers, retailers,
collectors, or agents. 17%
more were professionals.
[LIPSET/RAAB, p. 82]
The third wave of
Jewish immigrants, the largest,
came from Eastern Europe
at the turn of the twentieth
century and mostly settled
in New York City; occupationally,
these Jews gravitated to
the clothing industry. Between
1881 and 1924 over two and
a half million Jews from
Russia alone came to America
aggravating -- with their
allegedly rude and "uncivilized"
mode of living -- not only
non-Jewish Americans but
indigenous Jewish -Americans
as well, who worried that
their Eastern European brethren's
"customs and manners ...
imperil[ed] their ascent."
[ZWEIGENHAFT, p. 12-13]
(A more recent
- -1980s -- Jewish immigration,
with the fall of the Shah, was that from Iran. "This," says the
Los Angeles Times,
"was one of the richest
waves of immigrants ever
to come to the United States.
Their first toehold in their
new land was no squalid,
crowded 'Little Tehran,'
but rather the gracious
hillsides of Trousdale Estates
in Beverly Hills, and other
nearby neighborhoods of
the Westside and San Fernando
Valley." [MITCHELL, p. J1] By the late 1980s, one of five students
in the posh Beverly Hills
(which is, as noted earlier,
mostly Jewish anyway) school
system were "Iranians";
most of these Iranians were
Jews. [MITCHELL, p. J1]
Hundreds of thousands
of Jews from Israel
have also emigrated
to America in recent years.
"I would ... venture a guess,"
says Israeli sociologist
B.Z. Sobel, "and suggest
that at least in the case
of the United States, the
Israelis currently arriving
represent the most gilded
of immigrant groups to reach
American shores in this
century." [SOBEL, B., p.
149] Jews from Israel in
America have been rated
with an economic "productivity
index of 6.8," the highest
of any ethnic group. "Those
Jewish immigrants from Israel,"
notes Steven Silbiger, "were
seven times more likely
to have the highest concentration
of higher incomes and the
lowest rate of dependency
on public assistance than
any other group studied."
[SILBIGER, S., 2000, p.
4]
Then
there are the recent Russian
Jewish immigrants to America
since the 1970s -- approximately
400,000 in the metropolitan
New York area alone. As
the Jerusalem Post
noted in 2000 about the
results of an American Jewish
Committee survey: "The Russians
are the most educated immigrant
group in America's immigrant
history and are more highly
educated than American Jews
as a whole ... after six
years in the U. S. most
of the employed Russians
are similar to American
Jews in terms of annual
income and attitude." [HENRY,
M., 1-13-00, p. 3])
"As early as 1885,"
notes Joel Kotkin, "...
Jews, mostly from Germany,
owned 97% of all the garment
factories. By the early
twentieth century Jewish
domination of the 'rag trade'
[in America] was virtually
complete, with Jews accounting
for between 50 and 80 per
cent of all haymakers, furriers,
seamstresses, and tailors
in the country." [KOTKIN,
p. 48-49] By 1915 the "clothing trade" was America's
third largest industry,
behind only steel and oil.
[LEACH, p. 93]
"Jews largely created
the American clothing production
industry, replacing homemade
clothes and tailor-made
clothing." [SILBIGER, S.,
2000, p. 46] "Jews," says
Milton Plesur, "were the
chief source of operatives
for the ready-made clothing
industry, but by the 1920s,
they constituted less than
half of the operatives and
by mid-century less than
28 percent. In the meantime,
Jews have risen to management
and ownership, thus achieving
almost exclusive control
of the entire wearing apparel
industry." [PLESUR, M.,
1982, p. 161] The modern
bra, for instance, was a
Jewish marketing invention,
promoted by the Maiden Form Brassiere company owned
by William and Ida Rosenthal
with Enid Bissett, founded
in 1923. Likewise, the suits
of "Hattie
Carnegie [born Herietta
Kanengeiser] led a fashion
empire that set the pace
of American fashion for
nearly three decades." [HYMAN,
p. 207]
In more recent
history, Jews have congregated
in, and dominated, the "fashion"
aspects of the clothing
industry
-- founding everything
from Guess,
Gitano, Jordache, Calvin Klein, and Levi-Strauss jeans to Ralph [Lifshitz] Lauren cosmetics. (The Jordache and Guess companies -- both founded by
recent Jewish immigrants
to the United States --
were involved in particularly
nasty lawsuits and underhand
unscrupulous maneuvers against
each other. The companies'
manipulations are documented
in a 1992 volume entitled:
Glamour, Greed, and Dirty
Tricks in the Fashion Industry:
The Bizarre Story of Guess
v. Jordache.
In 1985, one of the
brothers who owns Jordache,
Joe Nakash, was elected
in Israel to be the president
of the Boys' Town Jerusalem
Society. "This is the message
I want to convey to those
who care about Israel's
future," Nakash said, "That
in addition to providing
its students with a superb
education, Boys' Town builds
and develops their character,
their conviction and their
commitment to their homeland."
[JEWISH WEEK, 5-3-85, p.
22]
At Levis-Strauss, in 1982 Robert Haas
"became the fifth generation
family member to run the
company (his father, Walter
A. Haas Jr. was CEO from
1958 to 1976." [MUNK, p.
36] Warren Hirsch, president
of Murjani
International initiated
the blue jean craze in recent
years with the designer
label "Gloria Vanderbilt." Alfred Slaner headed
Kayser-Roth
into the 1980s, "the
largest clothing manufacturing
establishment in the world."
[GREENBERG, M., p. 73]
French-born
Maurice Bidermann (born
Maurice Zylberberg) "was
the mastermind of one of
the largest [clothes] manufacturing
networks in the world, with
thirteen thousand workers
in thirty-four factories.
Producer of Pierre Cardin and Yves Saint Laurent suits, his plants
in France, the United States
and Hong Kong churned out
nearly $200 million in designer
duds each year ... He was
the older brother of Regine,
the jet-set nightclub owner
of New
Jimmy's and Regine's,
in Paris and New York."
[GAINES/CHURCHER, p. 196]
The president of
Bidermann's companies in
the U.S.? Also Jewish. Michael
Zelnick.
"Of all the monarchs
in the garment industry,"
note Steven Gaines and Sharon
Churcher, "... Carl Rosen
[of Puritan
Fashions; Chief Financial
Officer: Sam Rubenstein]
was the biggest and richest
... Rosen owned two
Rolls-Royces, both painted
gold, and the one he kept
at his Palm Springs estate
once belonged to the queen
mother of England ... Reportedly
... Carl supplied hookers
and dirty weekends to Las
Vegas for the buyers." [GAINES/CHURCHER,
p. 216] "The [Dan] Millstein name [of coats and suits]
had become familiar to every
American household ... [Seymour] Fox was in a league of his own in the
fashion business, a mogul
even wealthier than Millstein.
Fox was known not only for
his exquisite, high-priced
fashions but for his grand
lifestyle, replete with
stretch limousines and a
beautiful mistress, the
Women's Wear Daily
columnist Carol Bjorkman."
[GAINES/CHURCHER, p. 49,
56]
In the 1960s and 1970s,
Hartmarx
"became the largest manufacturer
and retailer of men's tailored
clothing." The company,
originally called Hart,
Schaffner and Marx,
was founded in the late
1800s by Harry and Marcus
Marx. Relative Joseph Schaffner
joined as a co-partner later.
[SONNENFELD, J., 1988, p.
167] In Canada, Steven
Shein owns E&J Manufacturing
Ltd., "one of Canada's largest
wool coat makers." [KUITENBROWER,
P., 4-1-2000, p. D1] Sigi
Rabinowicz, an Orthodox
Jew, is the CEO of Israel-based
Tefron,
"a major force in lingerie."
[MCLEAN, B., 9-18-2000,
p. 60] "Israel Myers
-- son of a tailor -- originated
the London Fog raincost."
[KRISCHNER, S., 9-14-00,
p. 11]
In 1995 another
Jewish garment mogul, Calvin
Klein, who had a serious
problem with cocaine and
Quaaludes over the years
[GAINES/CHURCHER, p. 208],
was condemned by a range
of parent and social welfare
groups for an advertising
campaign featuring images
by Jewish photographer Stephen
Meisel. Adolescent models,
notes Henry Giroux, were
photographed
"in various stages
of undress, poised to offer
both sexual pleasures and
the fantasy of sexual
availability ... Angry critics
... called the images
suggestive and exploitive,
and condemned Calvin
Klein for using
children as sexual
commodities. Other critics
likened the ads to child
pornography." [GIROUX,
p. 16-17]
This was an old theme
for Klein. Earlier suggestive
commercials with and adolescent
Brooke Shields had garnered
condemnation from a variety
of groups, including a feminist
group called Women Against
Pornography.
(Klein's key partner in
his initial years was fellow
Jewish entrepreneur Barry
Schwartz. Another Jewish
friend, described as Klein's
"mentor," was Nicholas de
Gunzburg, the "fur and fabric
editor" of Vogue
magazine). [GAINES/CHURCHER,
p. 97-98]
The Guess company (founded by the Jewish
Marciano brothers, who share
control of the firm with
the Nakash family, who are
also Jewish) has also followed
the same advertising strategy
to sell jeans. "Media Watch,"
noted the Los Angeles
Times in 1990, "a feminist
group in Santa Cruz, has
called for a boycott of
Guess, charging that its ads demean
women, integrating sex with
violence." [SCHACTER, J.,
1990, p. D1]
Elsewhere, Estelle
Sommers founded the Capezio
dancewear brand, Ann
Klein [originally Hannah
Golofski] has become a widely
recognized "designer" brand,
as has Donna
Karan and her DKNY label. Isaac Mizrahi and Tommy Hilfiger are other famous Jewish
fashion brands, as is that
of the Iranian-Jewish mogul
of perfume and self-promotion,
Bijan
(Pakzad), also known as
the "designer of what's
probably the world's most
expensive menswear." [DORFMAN]
Rudi
Gernreich and John
Weitz are other Jews
who have been prominent
fashion designers. Designer
Arnold Scassi's last name is Isaacs
(his original surname) spelled
backwards. Kenneth Cole (originally: Kenneth Cohen)
developed popular lines
of shoes, belts, and leather
jackets. Judith Lieber manufacturers luxury
handbags. Liz
Claiborne founded her
company with her Jewish
husband Arthur Ortenberg
and Leonard Boxer. She retired
in 1989 whereupon Jerome
Chazen became chairman of
the firm. Other prominent
executives in the company
are Harvey Falk and Jay
Margolis.
In 1988, Nicholas
Coleridge listed the American
"power buyers" (those who
buy for stores) of the fashion
world. Most of the people
listed are Jewish, and a
huge percentage of the stores
are Jewish-owned:
"Daria Retain, fashion
director of Neiman Marcus;
Ellin Saltzman,
director of fashion
and product development
at Saks Fifth Avenue;
James Fowler and Mary
Talbot, vice-president and
design buyer
of Jacobsons Stores,
Michigan; Kaye von Bergen,
designer buyer
of Bendel's; Lois
Ziegler and Sue Bicksler,
fashion directors of
J.C. Penney; Bernie
Ozer, vice-president of
the Associated
Merchandising Corporation;
Barbara Weiser of Charivari;
Barbara
Warner, formerly of
Barneys, who virtually single-handedly
turned
the store into an
upbeat designer terminus;
Lynne Manulis, president
of Marthas; Joan Weinstein,
president of Ultimo; James
Sullivan,
fashion director of
Jordan Marsh; Missy Lomonaco,
fashion
director of Bonwit
Teller; Betty Hahn, designer
buyer of Garfinkels,
Washington; Jean Navin,
vice-president and fashion
director of
Lord & Taylor;
Kal Ruttenstein, vice-president
and fashion director
of Bloomingdales;
Terry Melville, fashion
director of Macy's; and
Sal Ruggerio of Marshall
Field, Chicago." [COLERIDGE,
p. 259]
In 2000, the National
Post noted the heart
of the garment district
in Montreal, Canada -- the
Jewish center of Chabenel
Street. The article addressed
the bribery of store buyers
by clothing makers and its
long tradition in the Jewish
community. (In Yiddish:
"Az men shmert nit, fort
men nit." -- If you don't
bribe, you don't ride).
Kickbacks, noted Doug Robinson,
a Canadian fraud squad officer
is "a dirty secret of the
industry." [KUITENBROWER,
P., 4-1-2000, p. D1]
Elsewhere, Israeli-born
Elia "Tahari
is among the most respected
names in department and
specialty stores." [HOOD,
p. 1E] In California Severin
Wunderman's company, the
Severin Group ($500 million a year
in sales), remains "the
sole manufacturer, marketer,
and distributor of Gucci
timepieces and Fila sports
watches."
These products' retail
cost run between $225 and
$14,000 apiece. "The word
'demanding' is repeatedly
used to describe [Severin].
In addition to shouting
and breaking things, he
has tossed more than one
cellular phone out the window
of his chauffeur-driven
Rolls Royce." [HOWLETT,
p. E1] The head of the French luxury
jewelry firm, Cartier,
is also Jewish: Alain Dominique
Perrin. In 1996, during
a visit to Israel, he announced
"plans to donate an unspecified
percentage of the revenue
from the sale of $10 million
worth of jewelry to WIZO
[the World International
Zionist Organization]."
[CASHMAN, 1996, p. 14] Kenneth
Jay Lane, "the fake jewelry
king," [HORYN, C., 12-12-99,
sec. 9, p. 1] is also Jewish.
Nudie Cohen, head of Nudie's,
was the "costume designer
who pasted Nashville in
rhinestones in the 1940s
and '50s." [LONGINO, M.,
9-8-2000] He supplied the
Hollywood/Las Vegas cowboy
image to people like Roy
Rogers and Gene Autry.
Others fitting such
stars were "Nathan Turk
and his East coast counterpart
Rodeo Ben (Bernard
Lichtenstein), both Eastern
European immigrants" whose
"clothes brought western
wear into its heyday." [MOORE,
B., 2001, p. E3] Adrian's
was the logo of Adrian Goldberg,
a famous dress designer
for Hollywood in the 1930s
and '40s. Sidney Toledano
is today's president and
CEO of Christian Dior.
The Chanel company, which makes "the most
expensive perfume in the
world," was founded by non-Jew
Co Co Chanel, but built
to power by the Jewish Wertheimer
brothers. As the London
Independent notes:
"In 1924 [Chanel]
sold 90 per cent of the
rights to Chanel No. 5
to Pierre Wertheimer,
who, with his brother Paul,
owned Bourjois,
the largest cosmetics
company in France ... They
bought out Chanel
-- couture house,
perfume and all -- in 1954."
[JOBEY, L., 11-27-90,
Feeling that "she was being cheated"
by the Wertheimers, Chanel
had sued them in 1934. [MOUBRAY,
J., 2-10-98, p. 18]
Elsewhere
in France, in 1995 Jean-Pierre
Meyer became Deputy Chairman
of the L'Oreal cosmetics
giant, suceeding Andre Bettencourt
(whose father founded the
firm). Meyer, who is Jewish,
is married to Bettencourt's
daughter. [ http://www.klarsfeld.org/press/95/us_urged/us_urged.htm
]
Diane von Furstenberg (original name:
Diane Simone Michelle Halfin)
founded a "fragrance and
fashion empire." Stanley
Kohlenberg, head of Revlon's domestic Group III, was "recognized
as one of the premiere marketing
men in the fragrance industry."
[GAINES/CHURCH, p. 182]
Samuel Rubin founded the
Faberge perfume company. Max Factor built a cosmetics empire,
including waterproof mascara
and long-lasting lipstick. Helena Rubenstein sold "beauty and
royalty."
"The names [of Jewish
entrepreneurs] Helena
Rubenstein and Estee
Lauder [born Josephine
Esther Menzer] became virtual
synonyms for cosmetics in
the twentieth century."
[HYMAN, p. 27] Adrien
Arpel opened 500 skin
care salons across America.
"A legend in the cosmetics
industry.... although Arpel is not a formally observant woman,
she is very conscious of
her Jewish identity." [HYMAN,
p. 67-68] Vidal Sassoon built an business empire
based on hair care. (Sassoon,
funder of a research unit
on anti-Semitism at an Israeli
university, was the recipient
of the first American Jewish
Congress "Beauty Hall of
Fame" award). Non-Jew Grace
Mirabella, for 17 years
the editor of Vogue
magazine, notes that "all
the models, actresses, and
photographers of London"
hung out a Sassoon's hair
studios. [MOIRABELLA, G.,
1995, p. 127]
Jack Rosen is chairman of
the Hazel
Bishop cosmetics company
(as well as being the CEO
and chairman of Continental Health Affiliates and the
CEO of Infu-Tech,
two major health care corporations).
[PR NEWSWIRE, 3-13-98] Shirley
Polykoff at Clairol introduced
to America her advertising
catchphrases: "'Does she
or doesn't she?,' 'If I
have only one life to lead,
let me live it as a blonde,'
and 'Hate that gray, wash
it away.'" [BAER, p. 158]
The Gottleib family
founded the Gottex
swimmear line. Marvin
Winkler (philanthropist
of an Orthodox Chabad "Immigrant
Camp" in Hollywood) and
Jay Schottenstein bought
the Gotcha surf wear company in 1996 (also
including the MCD
and GirlStar brands. Adam Tihany is one
of America's best known
upscale "restaurant designers,"
his work includes Manhattan's
Le Cirque 2000. Maurice
Stein owns Burbank, "one of the world's largest
suppliers of cosmetics,
skin, and hair products
to the entertainment industry."
[WILGOREN, p. A1]
Israeli-born Gil
Gamlieli is co-owner of
"Manhattan's celebrated
Gil Gamlieli Beauty Group." [EPSTEIN,
M., p. T6]
Even a Satmar hasidic
Jew, Victor Jacobs, is CEO
and Chairman of Allou Health and Beauty Care.
Chicago's Irving Harris
became a millionaire with
his ToniHome Permanent. Mr. Blackwell -- creator of the world's "worst" and
"best" dressed lists, is
a Jewish fashion designer
who changed his name from
Richard Selzer to Dick Ellis
to, lastly, Blackwell. Britain's
Trevor Spero founded the
Flame
model agency and Scene
magazine, which covers the
fashion industry. New York's
Fashion Institute of Technology "grew
from the dream of a small
group of successful Eastern
European Jewish immigrant
manufacturers ... [who ultimately
created] a thriving college
of art and design, business
and technology. [NEWSDAY,
p. A39] FIT's chairman of the board was
still in Jewish hands in
1998, in the person of Edwin
Goodman. "By the late 1930s," notes Henry Feingold,
"Jews could be also found
in the creative departments
of the full-service advertising
agencies as the experts
in marketing surveys, motivation
research, and the psychology
of consumption." [FEINGOLD,
p. 104]
Brett Goldberg sells
Dead Sea mud as a skin lotion.
His business (Ahava's hand cream) took off when he
met and married Eve Berenblum,
head of Sak's cosmetics department. The American-born
Goldberg has dual American-Israeli
citizenship and volunteered
for the Israeli army. [BERMAN/SANDERS,
1-11-99] Sydell Miller and her husband Arnold
started Matrix
Essential, a hair care
and skin products company.
Sidney Kimmel heads the
Jones Apparel Group; its clothing lines
include Jones
New York, Evan-Picone, Saville, NineWest shoe stores, and movie production
interests. The CEO of the
Jo Ann Stores chain (1065 stores nationwide;
also sometimes called Cloth World and Jo Ann Fabrics) is Alan Rosskamm. Co-founded
by his father, the firm's
1997 sales alone were $975
million. Bob Sockolow is
the president and CEO of
San-Francisco based Rochester Big and Tall Clothing. The
founders of the Banana
Republic clothing retail
chain were Bill Rosenszweig,
and Mel and Patricia Ziegler.
The Eddie
Bauer outdoor clothing
empire is headed of course
by Eddie Bauer; he is also
Jewish. Jeffrey Swartz is
the president and CEO of
the Timberland shoe and boot firm.
The 2002 CEO of the Cherokee
clothing chain is Bobby
Margolis.
In 1997 The Limited Inc. (Leslie Wexner, CEO)
was accused by the AFL-CIO
of subcontracting garment
work in the Dominican Republic
that paid workers $21 for
an 80-hour work week. The Limited's 3,000 outlets and brands
include Abercrombie
and Fitch, Structure,
Express, Lane Bryant, Henri Bendel, Bath & Body Works, and Victoria's Secret, among others. [FORWARD,
5-30-97, p. 1] (Abercrombie
and Fitch's 2001 summer
catalogue attracted a coalition
of groups as diverse as
the National Organization
for Women and Concerned
Christian Americans in protest.
The catalogue was condemned
as "soft porn." An earlier
A&F catalogue
-- Naughty or Nice
-- was "denounced" by the
Michigan attorney general's
office.") [CRARY, D., 6-22-01]
In 1986, Linda Wachner,
also Jewish, president of
Max Factor, U.S. Division, maneuvered
a hostile takeover of the
Warnaco
Group, effectively seizing
control of much of the women's
underwear market (including
the brand names Warners, Olga, Valentino, Scaagi, Ungaro, Bob Mackie, and Fruit of the Loom). Wachner was henceforth
the CEO of Wanaco,
"one of the highest paid
and most powerful businesswomen
in America in the 1990s."
[HYMAN, p. 27]
Elsewhere, Howard
Gross is the CEO of Miller's
Outpost's chain of 220
stores; Robert Siegel became
the CEO of the Stride Rite store chain in 1993. Donald
Fisher is founder and CEO
of the giant clothes retailer
The Gap. He too is Jewish, [ALTMAN-OHR,
A., 4-14-2000, p. 64A]
as is Millard Drexler,
another top executive at
the company.
By 1984 41%
of Jewish households had
an income of $50,000 or
more, four times the proportion
of non-Hispanic whites.
[SILBERMAN, p. 118; SILBIGER,
S., 2000, p. 4] And while
Jews constitute just 2.5
per cent of the American
population, by 1990 more
than twice as many Jews
as non-Jewish whites had
household incomes over $50,000
a year; the average Jewish
American's income was also
two to three times higher
than the average of all
other Americans. Two-thirds
of all adult American Jews
between the ages of 25 and
64 had graduated from colleges
or universities, worked
as professionals or managers,
and lived in households
with incomes over $50,000
per year. [ZUCKERMAN, A.
p. 22] As 2.5% of America's population, by
the late 1980s Jews "accounted
for 13% of executives under
the age of 40." [ROIPHE/CHANES,
p. 451]
By 1990, almost 90%
of American Jews were in
white-collar occupations.
The rest tended to work
as jewelers, watchmakers,
waiters, hairdressers, cosmetologists,
electronic repair technicians,
or in security careers. [HARTMAN, p. 118] "The pace of socio-economic
change," says Calvin Goldschieder
and Alan Zuckerman, "and
the levels attained are
exceptional features of
Jews compared to non-Jews."
[LIPSET, Unique,
p. 3]
In a study of Boston
Jews in 1975, 60% of Jewish
males in the work force
were categorized as professionals.
One quarter of them were
physicians. Less than 3%
of Boston's male Jewish
workforce (ages 30-39) could
be classified as "workers."
[GOLDSCHIEDER, JOBS, p 5]
By 1996, Jews were
"two to three times more
likely to work as professionals
or managers than other Americans
... For several decades
now, Jews have been distinguished
by their extraordinary socioeconomic
achievements." [WILDER,
E., 6-96]
For Jews of
Eastern European heritage,
their dramatic trajectory
of wealth building in America
has occurred in the last
century or so. "The Jewish
explanation for their common
affluence," says Liebman
and Cohen, "is 'the myth
of the lower East Side,'
according to which Jews
arrived in the United States
as an impoverished group
and by dint of hard work,
sacrifice, and determination
rose to prosperity ... It
is not too far-fetched to
suggest that this myth also
alleviates the guilt that
Jews may feel over their
present prosperity and material
comfort." [LIEBMAN/COHEN,
p. 17]
"Even when compared
to others of similar social
characteristics," says Stephen
Whitfield, "such as years
of education, Jewish families
still earn more. Even in
families with no one working,
Jewish families earn more."
[WHITFIELD, American,
p. 7]
"Jewish academics,"
noted Marshall Sklare in
1974, "... are also considerably
more prosperous on the average
than their Gentile counterparts."
[SKLARE, 1974, p. 20] "Earnings
from investments of one
sort or another are apparently
greater among Jews," notes
economist Thomas Sowell,
"as are other advantages
based on the past." [KREFETZ,
p. 8]
Asserting fears of
anti-Semitism, Jews try
to keep their collective
economic power from being
widely known by non-Jews.
"Some Jews," writes Edward
Shapiro, "are embarrassed
by references to Jewish
affluence for fear that
any discussion will encourage
the anti-Semitic stereotype
of vast Jewish wealth and
economic power ... Marxists,
true to the teachings of
the founder of their cult,
have continued to identify
Jews and Judaism (and now
Israel) with commercial
exploitation and capitalism.
Little wonder, then, that
Jews and their friends,
despite evidence to the
contrary, and even though
they themselves know better,
prefer to deny, ignore,
or explain away Jewish wealth.
... Jews would prefer to believe, and have
others believe, that they
are like everyone else,
only more so. This stance
has the advantage of not
attracting attention." [SHAPIRO,
p. 9] "Given that the myth of the 'all-powerful
Jew' is identified with
Nazi propaganda," says Lenni
Brenner, "it should not
surprise us that there are
still many people who are
squeamish about bringing
attention to the sociological
changes that have converted
a community once unique
in America for its mass
radicalism into a pillar
of capitalism." [BRENNER,
p. 61] "Even today,"
noted Steven Silbiger in
2000, "many Jewish people
would rather reserve the
subject of their success
for private conversations
rather than fuel the fires
of anti-Semitism. Older
Jewish-Americans, in particular,
have downplayed their success
and their Judaism in an
effort to avoid unwanted
attention and possible trouble."
[SILBIGER, S., 2000, p.
3]
Harry Golden
notes Jewish economic standing
in a religion-based report
in the 1957 Bureau of Census
survey and Jewish organization
attempts to hide this information:
"This report, intended
to furnish data on the economic
and social
characteristics of
Protestants, Catholics,
and Jews, was almost
immediately suppressed
at the insistence of religious
organizations
and groups. Notable
among these groups and organizations
were
the Jewish social-action
agencies, who feared the
news about
Jewish incomes, education
levels, and mobility would
feed
anti-Semitism." [GOLDEN,
H., 1973, p. 6]
"From Buenos Aires
to Baghdad," says Joshua
Halberstam, "from the days
of Rome to the present,
the world talks about Jews
and their special relationship
to wealth ... The really
peculiar part of these slogans
about Jews and money ...
is the equivocation with
which Jews react to the
charges ... Proud of their
financial achievements,
American Jews often congratulate
themselves and their success,
but when a non-Jew points
to the same Jewish affluence,
American Jews become extremely
nervous and suspect lurking
anti-Semitism." [HALBERSTAM,
p. 10] "Writing about money and Jews is inflammatory
no matter how cautious it
is handled," wrote Gerald
Krefetz in an apologetic
introduction to his book,
Jews and Money, (1982),
"As I examined the available
literature on the subject
it became clear to me that
in recent years no one had
scrutinized the scope of
contemporary Jewish economic
activity in America. The
reason for this neglect
was not hard to find: ...
the subject of Jews and
money was best not discussed
for fear of raising the
anti-Semitic ghost again."
[KREFETZ, p. ix, x] When
Jewish economic power is
(rarely) openly addressed,
Jewish dissimulation strategy
is usually to emphasize
the risky, precarious nature
of their business dealings
and their supposed relative
marginality to the American
social, economic, and political
system. [SHAPIRO, p. 9]
"Those who do
not want to confront the
reality of the wealth of
the richest portions of
modern Jewry," notes Brenner,
"tend to overemphasize the
poverty of the poorest section."
[BRENNER, p. 61] In 1983,
for instance, some Jewish
organizations were claiming
that 13-15% of American
Jewry was "economically
disadvantaged and vulnerable."
Such a figure, however,
notes Lenny Brenner, is
afforded by an American
Jewish Committee study which
defines "poverty among Jews
at 150 per cent of the Federally
defined poverty level ...
Two-thirds of the poor are
elderly. A large proportion
of these are widows." As
early as 1955, researchers
were noting that Jews were
"underrepresented in the
population below or close
to the poverty line." [WEYL,
1968, p. 173] As early as
1902, Isaac Max Rubinow,
a Jewish medical inspector
for the New York Board of
Health wrote:
"I must express my conviction
(which will evoke protest
among the intelligentsia
of New York) that the Jewish
masses are better off economically
than the other
immigrants [to America],
and extreme poverty is not
prevalent in the Jewish
section.
I think that Iam familar
with the horrors of dire
poverty. As a medical inspector
for the New
York Board of Health I had
to spend several months
in the poorer sections of
Brooklyn.
When I beheld the privations
of the Irish, the Italians,
the Negroes and
others, I had to admit that
the condtion of the Russian-Jewish
mases is more or less satisfactory."
[RUBINOW, I., 1959, p. 96]
"The percentage of Jewish
households with income less than
$20,000 is half that of
non-Jews." [SILBIGER, S.,
2000, p. 4] The Jewish working
class appears to be vanishing
from all but the largest
communities," wrote Jewish
sociologist Marshall Sklare
in 1955, "-- the phenomenon
of an American Jewish working
class may turn out to be
characteristic only of the
immigrant era." [SKLARE,
M., 1955, p. 215]
"It is disingenuous
to pretend," says W. D.
Rubenstein,
"that since the end
of the war there has not
been a fundamental
change in the status
of Western Jewry ... Understandable
reluctance
to discuss Jewish
socio-economic advantage
in an explicit fashion has
led to the neglect
of an important trend: the
steady rise of Western
Jewry into the upper-middle
class, together with the
broadening of
Jewish membership
in the institutional elites
of most Western countries
... The rise
of Western Jewry to unparalleled
affluence and high status
has led to the near-disappearance
of a Jewish proletariat
of any size:
indeed, the Jews may
become the first ethnic
group in history without
a working class of
any size." [RUBENSTEIN,
p. 51]
This increasingly
elite caste status for Jews
throughout the world is
not true in Israel, of course,
because that country's population
is largely Jewish. Any elite
caste depends upon-- and
is supported by -- a large
sub-caste beneath it. Although
there is an institutionally
enforced Arab underclass
in Israel, the assumption
of wealth, power, and status
for all
Jews as
a class in that nation
is impossible because it
necessitates the economic
exploitation of the local
population, which is largely
other Jews too. This, notes
Israeli sociologist Sammy
Smooha, poses a paradoxical
problem for the Judeocentric
Israeli state: "In contrast
to Jews in western societies
where they constitute a
negligible minority (for
instance, Jews in the U.S.
number only 2.5 percent
of the population) and where
therefore most of them can
reach the highest strata,
most Jews in Israel cannot
be in top positions as long
as Jews make up 85% or more
of the population." [SMOOHA,
S., p. 176] Or as Jay Gonen, another Israeli commentator,
put it:
"Everywhere
in the world the Jews are
the most successful businessmen,
but not
in
Israel, everywhere else
they are financial wizards,
but not in Israel. You know
why? Because here in Israel
they can only deal with
other Jews." [GONEN, J.,
1975,
p. 274]
What is not explicitly stated here by such Jewish
commentators (although it
is certainly inferred) is
that the Jewish diaspora's
economic, political, and
social self-advancement
in capitalist society --
as a collectivity -- is
contingent upon the exploitation
of Gentiles below it. In Israel, by the
demographic dictates of
Israeli policy that insist
upon a strong Jewish population
dominance, (even with the
import of cheap Arab labor
from Gaza and the West Bank)
there are not enough exploitable
non-Jews to go around. (One
might argue, however, that
the $3 billion a year the
United States government
provides for the Jewish
state, and similar funds
from other nations, thanks
to international Jewish
lobbying, is a collective
kind of exploitation of
non-Jewish lands). Per
Israel, Israeli scholar
Simha Flapan notes that
"the 1.25 million Palestinians
who came under Israeli rule
provide cheap labor for
the Israeli economy, supplying
nearly 100,000 workers for
agriculture, public works,
construction, light industries,
and private services. The
Palestinians became Israel's
'water carriers and hewers
of wood.' Jewish workers
moved up the social ladder
to positions of management,
the professions, trade,
and public service." [FLAPAN,
S., 1987, p. 239]
All this, of course, has
profound implications. Harry
Triandis, while not addressing
the Jewish dimensions to
the issue, notes the broader
context in America for the
growing elite as a significant
part of the American upper
classes:
"The gulf between
the rich and the poor is
becoming larger. In
the 18th century
the gross national product
per capita ... of the
rich was twice
that of the poor; in 1950
this ratio had become
50 to 1; in
1990 it was 70 to 1." [TRIANDIS,
p. 15]
Today's Jewish high
status and attendant world
view represent the material
opposite of much of immigrant
American Jewry's sense of
itself at the turn of the
twentieth century. As Hania
Diner notes:
"Both left-wing radicalism
and Zionism shaped the political
and
ideological lives
of many Jews who emigrated
to the United States
beginning in the 1880s
... [DINER, p. 7] ... Socialism
proved such an
attractive political
philosophy to these immigrant
Jews because
of the brutal sweatshop
conditions under which so
many worked,
usually in factories
owned by other Jews ...
[DINER, p. 9] ... [In 1925]
such predominantly
Jewish unions as the ILGWU,
the United
Cloth Hat and Cap
Makers, and the Furrier's
Union all sent
[communist] May Day
greetings to ... the black
socialist magazine,
the Messenger."
[DINER, p. 202]
This radically universalist
expression, or whatever
else it was (transitory
strategy to deconstruct
the existing Christian-oriented
culture?), has proven over
the years to have been remarkably
illusory and shallow-- merely
a means to a self-promotive
end -- as Jewry has quickly
ascended the American economic
ladder. As Arthur Hertzberg
notes about America's early
twentieth century Russian
Jewish population, supposedly
rooted so deeply in socialist
ethics, "Jews were uniquely
visible in this stampede
toward wealth because they
were moving more rapidly
upward from the poverty
of their youth than any
other group in America.
This intense passion for
success was noted by others,
and not always with approval."
[HERTZBERG, A., 1989, p.
331]
(In Latin America
too, notes Judith Elkin,
immigrant Jews were quick
to dismiss their European-based
socialist political radicalism
in their new environments:
"Jews had never developed
linkages with non-Jewish
campesinos; ... Contact with the proletariat
was broken. This is a startling
fact, considering that so
large and so vocal a portion
of Jewish immigrants arrived
with leftist and universalist
ideals.")
[ELKIN, 1998, p.
148]
As Nathan Glazer noted about
the American social and
political world in 1971:
"All the roles that
Jews play are roles that
the New Left disapproves
of,
and wishes to reduce
... [The Left is critical]
of all private business,
and of its whole associated
institutional complex --
lawyers,
stockbrokers, accountants,
etc. -- in which Jews are
prominent.
The kinds of society
it admires have no place
for occupations in which
Jews have tended to
cluster in recent history."
[SHAPIRO, E., 1999,
As early as the mid-twentieth
century, American Jewry
was already largely stratified
out of the traditional "working
class." In a survey of 14
American cities between
1948-53, proportions of
Jews in "non-manual positions
(i.e., proprietors, managers,
administrators, officials,
clerks, salespeople, etc.)
ranged from 75 to 96% of
the Jewish working population."
[SKLARE, p. 138] "The distinction
between manual and non-manual
work," wrote Nathan Glazer
in 1958, in reviewing the
survey,
"is
today considered a crucial
one for determining the
social status of
individuals
and groups ... [GLAZER,
MIDDLE, p. 139] ... The rise
in
the proportion of professionals
has been accompanied by
a fall
in
the number of Jews engaged
in the lower-levels of white-collar
work
-- as clerks and salesmen
... The rapid decline in
the numbers
of
Jewish secretaries and salesmen
in recent years is a phenomenon
apparent
to the naked eye; the available
figures support this
impression
... [GLAZER, p. 139] ...
What has happened ... is
that
the Jewish economic advantages,
already perfectly obvious
in
the thirties ... has borne
fruit in the fifteen years
of prosperity
since
1940." [SKLARE, p. 139]
(By 1970, one-third
of one percent of
American
Jews were involved in manual
labor occupations.
Glazer
found the 1953 research
intriguing for other reasons
too. No matter what field
of economic endeavor Jews
chose, and no matter where
they chose it in America,
Jews earned more money than
non-Jews, even those in
the same locale, with the
same education, and the
same occupation. To explain
this endemic disparity,
Glazer notes that
"Ultimately, social
explanations must resort
to history, and explain
a
present peculiarity
by discovering any earlier
one. We think the
explanation
for the Jewish success in
America is that the Jews,
far
more than any
other immigrant group, were
engaged for generations
in
the middle-class
occupations, the professions,
and buying and selling."
"Whereas many [immigrant]
Poles," says Andrew Heinze,
"looked for unskilled jobs
in the steel industry and
thus settled in industrial
towns like those of Pennsylvania,
Jews from the same part
of the Old World concentrated
in major cities where they
could work in skilled and
semi-skilled trades and
in retailing, the occupations
for which they were prepared
... Digging coal, forging
steel, laying railroad track,
and building bridges did
not bring newcomers into
contact with the trends
and nuances of American
fashion. The manufacture
and sale of ladies' underwear,
children’s' dresses, and
men’s' suits did." [HEINZE,
p. 99]
University of Michigan
professor Arthur Evans Wood
noted in 1955 some interesting
information in his sociological
study of the Polish enclave
of Hamtramck in Detroit.
70% of the 43,000 residents
of Hamtramck were (non-Jewish)
Poles or of Polish (also
peasant) heritage, attracted
there to work in local automobile
factories. The City Attorney
for the city was Jewish,
however, William Cohen.
Although there were few,
if any, Jews living in Hamtramck,
he also was co-owner of
one of the city's two main
newspapers, the Hamtramck
Citizen. "A fascinating
additional reminder of an
old world situation," wrote
Wood,
"is to be found in
the dependence of the Poles
in Hamtramak upon
the Jewish attorney,
Bill Cohen, for frequent
legal services. The
relationship is somewhat
like that between the village
folk and the
Jewish tavern keeper
[in the Old Country] ...
The serviceableness
of Cohen to various
and opposed Polish [political]
factions over
the years is reminiscent
of an old Polish proverb,
'Jak bida, to
do zyda.' (when in need go to the Jew)."
[WOOD, A.E., p. 80, 233,
84]
Edward
Kantowicz, in his study
of Polish Americans in Chicago,
notes
"Throughout
much of partitioned Poland,
Polish-Jewish relations
consisted
of
Polish peasants bargaining
for goods or money with
Jewish shopkeepers
and
moneylenders. Such an economic
relation led often to ill
feelings and
a
pervasive sentiment among
peasants that they were
being exploited by
the
Jews. In America, Poles
and Jews often ended up
in a similar economic
relationship.
Whereas the peasant Poles
generally took up industrial
work
in
the New World, the Jews
frequently continued in
occupations similar
to
those they had practiced
in the Pale. Thus the business
streets of
[Chicago's]
Polonia were lined with
many shops and stores owned
by
immigrant
Jews, and the Poles again
found themselves dealing
day by
day
with Jewish shopkeepers
and moneylenders. Very early
this caused
resentment.
In 1895 one Polish newspaper
called for an increased
Polish
effort
to establish and patronize
their own businesses since
'the Jews, the
leeches
of Polish society, have
monopolized business in
this section of
town."
[KANTOWICZ, E., 1975, p.
118]
A
1950s-era study of the Jews
of Detroit, Michigan, found:
"There are extremely large
differences in the occupational
structures of Jewish, Catholic,
and Protestant families.
A large majority of the
heads of Jewish families
hold white-collar jobs (73
percent); the heads of non-Jewish
families, especially Catholics
and Negro Protestants, are
heavily concentrated in
the blue-collar occupations.
Jewish family heads are
particularly clustered in
the 'proprieter,
manager, and official' classification.
The proportion of Jews in
these 'tradesmen'
jobs (42 percent) is between
three and four times greater
than that for Catholics
or white Protestants ...
The contrast in occupational
distribution of the fathers
of Jewish and non-Jewish
family headds is enormous.
Approximately 75 percent
of the non-Jewish fathers
were in farming or held
blue-collar jobs, whereas
almost
the same proportion of Jewish
fathers were in white-collar
occupations. Many of
the Jewish fathers who held
white-collar jobs were probably
hucksters, peddlers,
or small trades, and merchants;
but the fact remains that
their background was
typically urban ... One
of the most striking features
of the economic status of
Jewish families in Detroit
is that almost one-half
of the family heads are
self-employed, although
only 10 per cent or less
of the heads of non-Jewish
Detroit area families
work for themselves ...
The median annual income
of the heads of Jewish families
during
the 1951 to 1954 period
ws $6,200. This figure is
considerably larger than
the median incomes of non-Jewish
family heads. The high Jewish
income, of course,
is related to the upper
occupational status of the
group. The large number
of Jewish family
heads who made $10,000 or
more annually is striking.
One-third of the heads
of Jewish families earned
this much money, as compared
with less than one-tenth
of the heads of non-Jewish
groups. [GOLDBERG/SHARP,
1960, p. 113, 114]
More recently, in
addressing the claim by
many Jews that their community
is "a light unto nations"
with higher moral standards
than others, Lenny Brenner,
a Jewish critic, notes that
"modern Judaism is a light
unto no one ... American
Judaism is the paradigm
of hollow worldly success."
[BRENNER, p 357] Concerning the possible movement by
some Jews from the Jewish
tradition of self-employment
into salaried professions
and the effect it could
have on donations to Jewish
causes, Steven Cohen remarks
that
"One need not be overly
cynical to realize that
self-employed
entrepreneurs
have a greater ability to
hide their income from the
Internal
Revenue Service
than do most salaried professionals."
[BRENNER, p.
In
recent years, according
to one Jewish count, of
the top fourteen American
billionaires, at least four
were Jewish. [SHAPIRO, p.
8] Of the 40 wealthiest
Americans, sixteen (40%)
were Jewish, as were 23%
of the four hundred richest
Americans. "Or," says Joshua
Halberstam, "to put this
another way, there are more
Jewish billionaires in the
United States than the total
number of billionaires of
France and England combined."
[HALBERSTAM, p. 12] Every year the Forbes "rich list"
as an extraordinarly disproportionate
number of Jews. Jewish author
Steven Silbiger examined
the 1999 Forbes "richest
400 people" list and announced
that
"Jewish
individuals accounted for
23 percent of the entire
group, 36 percent of
the
top fifty and 24 percent
of the billionaires -- eleven,
eighteen, and twelve times
times
their relative percentage
in the U.S. population at
large. And these percentages
in
the Forbes 400 have been
consistent over time, although
the players change
from
year to year; studies of
the lists from 1982, 1983,
and 1984 conducted by
others
reveal similar figures."
[SILBIGER, S., 2000, p.
86]
Silbiger,
investigating who exactly
of this list was Jewish,
explored public information
sources and knowledgeable
Jewish organizations. As
Silbiger discovered, 15
of these moguls do not wish
to be known publicly, at
least in this wealth context,
as Jewish; the rest of Silbiger's
1999 list is rendered here. An earlier (1980)
list of America's wealthiest
Jews may be found here.
As early as 1955 a researcher
suggested that 20% of America's
millionaires were Jewish,
and Jewry at-large accounted
for 10% of America's total
personal income, [WEYL,
1968, p. 173] about four
times their percentage of
the population. By 1973,
Harry Golden noted that
"New York [the heart of
the American business and
communications empire] is
the one city Jews transformed
into a Jewish city. They
are the warp and woof of
its fabric ... Jews own
roughly 80 percent of New
York City's businesses."
[GOLDEN, H., 1973, p. 8-9]
And
the other American economic
and mass media nerve center:
Los Angeles? As Joel Kotkin
noted in 2001,
"In
the neighborhoods and marketplaces
that comprise 21st-century
Los Angeles,
two ethnic groups predominate:
Jews and Latinos. Although
others, including
Asians,
Africian Americans and Anglo
Gentiles, play important
roles, these two
groups shape the social,
economic and cultural contours
of the city ... Jews reign
over many of the most dynamic
parts of the city's economy,
from Hollywood to
real estate, from cyberspace
to the garment business.
They are well-represented
at
both the elite and grass-roots
levels of L.A. business.
Jews, whether from Eastern
Europe or the Middle East,
boast among the highest
entrepreneurship rates of
any
group in the city's ethnic
mosaic, according to Cal
State Northridge demographer
James Allen; nearly half
the Los Angeles Business
Journal's list of richest
Angelenos
are Jews ... Unlike Jews
and Gentiles, or African
Americans, Jews and Latinos
share
little history or mythology.
For the most part, their
contacts have been opportunistic.
Jews have employed Latinos
in garment factories, as
maids and gardeners and
serviced them as customers
in a host of enterprises
from Whittier Boulevard
to
Santee Alley and Pico-Union." [KOTKIN,
J., 3-25-01, pt. M, p. 1]
In 1999, Jewish
Canadian billionaires included
Barry Sherman ($1.83 billion),
Leslie Dan ($1.56 billion),
and Saul Feldberg ($1 billion).
Sherman is chairman and
CEO of the Apotex
pharmaceutical firm, and
Dan heads rival Novopharm
Ltd. "[These] two Toronto-based
companies control about
90 percent of Canada's market
for generic, low-cost drugs."
[CANADIAN PRESS NEWSWIRE,
2-6-97] Sherman "donates
heavily to Jewish causes
and the state of Israel."
[THOMPSON, A. 2-11-92, p.
C1] Dan funded a CD-Rom
produced by Israel's Yad
Vashem "to help teach the
Holocaust." [CANADIAN JEWISH
NEWS, 12-5-96] (From America,
Harold Snyder
founded Biocraft Laboratories,
a manufacturer of drugs,
in 1964. It was sold to
the largest pharmaceutical
company in Israel , Teva,
in 1996, an organization
where Snyder serves as a
board member.) [MOTHER JONES,
5-3-01] The third Jewish
Canadian billionaire, Feldberg,
a Holocaust survivor, moved
to Israel, and later to
Canada. He heads the Global
Group and the Teknion
Corporation, two office
furniture conglomerates.
[GILBERT, N., 7-2-98, p.
15] In earlier years, Max
Tanenbaum was "the leading
Jewish industrialist in
Canada." [DRABINSKY, G.,
1995, p. 120]
Also in Canada, "the
proportion of Jews earning
over $75,000 [per year]
in 1991 was close to four
times that in the Canadian
population as a whole."
[SINGER/SELDIN, 1995, p.
235] In Spain, by 1991 the
Koplowitz family's construction
empire was worth $1.2 billion.
In France, when Marcel
Dassault [born Marcel Bloch]
died in 1987 he was "the
richest man in France."
[FONG, p. 148] He was a
member of the French Parliament
and had founded the aviation
company that manufactured
the Mirage fighter jet.
Dassault was born a Jew,
but formally converted to
Christianity. Another French
mogul of Jewish descent,
Marcel Blaustein-Blanchet
died in 1996. He was the
founder and chairman of
Publicis, "the giant advertising company
he founded as a teenager."
Blaustein-Blanchet "gave
France its first advertising
agency, its first radio
news program, and its first
opinion polls." [THOMAS,
R., 1996, p. 50] Publicis has offices today in 19 countries
(top two executives in 1996:
Elizabeth Badinter and Michael
Levy). Also, "the Citroen,
one of France's most popular
cars, is named for a Jew [Andre-Gustave Citroen] who was a pioneer
in France's automotive industry
... During World War I he
produced munitions for the
French government, but at
the war's end he turned
to the mass production of
automobiles." [GOLDBERG,
M. H., 1976, p. 108-109]
[Today's richest person in France
in 2002?]
According to Forbes
magazine, by 1998 Michael
Dell was the seventh richest
person on the planet, worth
$16.5 billion, and also
the youngest to have ever
been listed on the Forbes
500 "rich list." He is the
head of the Dell computer company, a direct-sales
firm. Dell is an active
philanthropist in the Austin,
Texas, Jewish community.
In 2001, Dell Ventues,
a division of Dell Computers,
announced plans to invest
in hi-tech development in
Israel. [GORDON, B., 1-21-01]
In 1999, the richest
man in Los Angeles was also
Jewish, Gary Winnick (worth
over $6 billion). "Winnick
is the fastest among today's
top entrepreneurs to make
his first billion dollars.
He did it in a breathtaking
18 months." [TUGEND, 10-1-99]
Syndicated columnist Richard
Reeves calls the first time
he ever saw Winnick "one
of the most disgusting events
I've endured in many years
of watching the way the
world works." Because Winnick
had paid a sizeable sum
for a Democratic Party fundraiser,
he was afforded time to
speak to the crowd. "This
egomaniac," wrote Reeves,
"who could afford the tab
got up and rambled on about
how rich and daring he was
and how great his kids were."
Then he put a cap with his
telecommunications company's
logo (Global Crossing) on
the head of Secreatry of
State Madeline Albright.
"It made you cringe to be
a citizen of the world's
greatest democracy," wrote
Reeves. "But that's the
way it works these days."
Winnick's company expected
to lay 100,000 miles of
fiber-optic cable to 27
countries and 200 cities
by mid-2001. He has pleged
$40 million to start an
institute named after himself
in Israel. "He also funds
other pro-Israel programs."[MOTHER
JONES, 5-3-01]
In Great Britain,
the (London) Daily Mail
noted a 1999 study by a
credit research organization,
Experian:
"A survey identifying
Britain's wealthiest family
names by their postcard
areas has produced
a fascinating insight into
the national makeup of
the 50 surnames
most common among the movers
and shakers...
More than 20
are from Jewish families
... There are more Cohens
in
the top group
than any other family name.
Just behind are Levy,
Bloom, and Wolf
... This [trend] is confirmed
by other surveys, for
instance the
Sunday Times Rich 1999,
which featured three Cohens,
Betterware multimillionaire Andrew,
Courts
furniture chain tycoon
Bruce, and DIY store boss Frank. Hugely wealthy
Levys include
59-year old
Peter, chairman of the London-based
Shaftsbury
property company,
while the Wolfs are represented
by Sir John, a
legend in Britain's
films." [POULTER, p. 19]
Jews
are approximately half of
one percent of England's
population, but, in 2001,
14 of them ranked among
Great Britian's 100 richest
people. Joe Lewis is the
wealthiest, worth 2.2 billion
pounds. "Mr. Lewis made
his fortune in the restaurant
trade and, subsequently,
in foreign exchange dealing."
Mark Pears (and family)
is worth about 600 million
pounds, owning about "20,000
flats and houses." Jewish
concerns of the Pears clan
include Maccabi Union and
Jewish Care. Gerald Ronson,
based in real estate, is
worth 75 million pounds,
and David Lewis and family
("fashion, property, travel,
and banking") are worth
350 million pounds. [LEVITT/KOHEN,
4-27-01, p. 14]
In
2002, the Jewish Chronicle
featured an article on the
results of a study of British
Jews: "London Jews comprise 'a relatively affluent group
of people with middle-class'
lifestyles, according to
a report published today
by the Institute for Jewish
Policy Research [A Portrait
of Jews in London and the
South East: A Community
Study, 'the largest
[survey] ever conducted
of Jews in Britain,' [2,965
people]. And, while details
of their income are being
kept under wraps, they are
'high on the socio-economic
scale.' Around one-third
describe themselves as employers
in large organisations or
in higher managerial and
professional occupations,
and another third in 'lower
professional and higher
technical and supervisiory'
work. Only one per cent
are engaged in 'routine'
occupations." [JeWISH
CHRONICLE, 12-6-02, p. 31]
The
story in Australia, where
Jews represent less than
a half of one percent of
population, is the same.
As that continent's Jewish
ethnic magazine Generation.
Jewish Life observed
in 2000:
"Every year they are out there for all to see. There it is, in
full salacious detail: the
BRW Rich List, that quintessence
of pennies envy, the vehicle
of voyeurism that
sums up the worst and most
popular features of modern
journalism. Each year, it
parades the names of Australia's
wealthiest, and the Jewish
ones are always prominent.
In fact, this year, their
collective wealth totaled
more than $23 billion, close
to 40 percent
of New Zealand's GDP. The
names themselves are all
too familiar. There's shopping
centre
king and former delivery
truck driver Frank Lowy
($2.6 billion) and the
cardboard magnate Richard
Pratt. They are the second
and third richest men in
Australia." [Others noted
include the Smorgon family,
Scheinberg family, Harry
Triguboff, Boris Lieberman,
John Gandel, Solly Lew,
Marc Besen, Nathan Werdiger,
Joseph
Gutnick, Ted Lustig, Max
Moar, Eddie Kornhauser,
Isador Magid, Barry|
and Norman Bloom, Chaim
Liberman, Morry Fraid, Ruben
Fried, Nathan Baron,
Henry Krongold, Isi Liebler,
Drvin Graf, Peter Joss,
Eddie Kornhauser, Henry
Roth,
Philip Wolanski, Rodney,
Kathy, and Roxanne Adler,
Ruth Simon and David Herrman]
... "The
Jews on the BRW list represent
a group that accounts for
a ridiculously small proportion
of the general population
-- only 0.4 percent in fact,
according to the 1996 Census.
So why the prominence?"
[GETTLER, L., 2000, p. 23]
Jewish
observer Leon Gettler suggests
possible reasons for Jewish
prominence in Australian
wealth-building, including
an immigrant ethic, Talmudic
principles, Jewish networking
("Maybe its just the tribal
nature of the Jews"), chutzpah
(pushiness), peer pressure
("keeping up with the Cohens"),
a this-world materialist
focus, and a survivalist
mentality. ("Many of the
Jews who graced the BRW
Rich Lists emerged from
the ashes of the Holocaust.")
[GETTLER, L., p. 23-27]
In America,
in comparison to other minority
communities, there are no
Hispanics and one Black
in the Forbes "richest 400
people" list, minority populations
that are larger in America
than their Jewish counterparts.
[LIPSET, p. 4] "When I read through the [1996] Newsweek
story of the 'Overclass
100,'" wrote Jewish journalist
Philip Weiss, "I began counting
the Jews, something I've
done since childhood, but
soon gave up, overwhelmed
by my tribe's prevalence
among the powerful, troubled
by what this means in the
new American class paradigm
of haves and have-nots."
[WEISS, p. 27]
"The Jewish economic
and social profile diverges
dramatically from that of
Gentile Americans," notes
Edward Shapiro, "Jews are
wealthier, more likely to
be found in the professions,
academia, and the upper
ranks of business, and attend
universities in greater
numbers ... Jews in Canada,
Central and South America,
and Europe exhibit the same
characteristics." [SHAPIRO,
E., 1998]
From a total American
Jewish population of about
six million, by 1992 Matti
Golan (an Israeli government
official) noted that over
300,000 Jewish households
(of a total population of
about six million people)
in America had incomes over
a million dollars a year.
[GOLAN p. 60]
"Will there be as
many Jews receiving Nobel
Prizes in the 21st century
as in the 20th?" wonders
Emanuel Rackman in the Jewish
Week, "There is cause
for pessimism in Jewish
circles, and I cannot dispel
it. The likelihood is that
more Jews will be in Forbes'
listing of multi-millionaires
but not on lists of those
making giant contributions
to the advancement of science
... Supreme value is now
placed on the acquisition
of wealth rather than intellectual
and moral excellence." [RACKMAN,
1-8-88, p. 24]
By 1993 the two most
highly paid corporate executives
in the U.S. were Jewish
-- one at a Hollywood studio,
and the other at a Wall
Street investment bank.
[CANTOR, p. 404] Most of
Jewish wealth is self-made
in the last century or so
(as opposed to Gentile-inherited
opulence), [WHITFIELD, American,
p. 7] a trajectory that
has no reason to plateau.
About half of the Jewish
super-rich built their fortunes
in real estate and construction,
most notably in the New
York City area, but also
all across the country,
including Detroit, San Francisco,
Miami, Washington DC, Indianapolis,
and Oklahoma City. [LIPSET,
p. 15] Edward S. Shapiro specifically cites
Jewish "real estate barons"
Alfred Taubman in Detroit,
Melvin Simon in Indianapolis,
Stephen Muss in Miami, Monte
and Alfe Goldman in Oklahoma
City and Walter Shorenstein
in San Francisco. [SHAPIRO,
1987, p. 14]
"In real estate and
construction," adds Abraham
Korman, "there have been
major Jewish builders in
San Francisco (Walter Shorenstein),
Detroit (Philip and Max
Stollman), New York (Samuel
Lefrak), and Washington
[DC] (Charles Smith) ...
Melvin Simon of Indianapolis
is one of the major shopping
center developers in this
country." [KORMAN, p. 24] The Simon Property Group is indeed
"the nation's largest mall
owner in the United States,
" including the Mall of
America in Minneapolis.
[MOTHER JONES, 5-3-01] "In
the construction and real
estsate fields," notes Milton
Presur, "there are such
giants as Webb and Knapp;
the Uris Brothers; Tishman;
Levitt; and Rudin and Wolfson
Enterprises." [PRESUR, M.,
1982, p. 163]
San Francisco's Walter
Shorenstein owns "one of
the nation's largest and
healthiest real estate empires,"
[KING, R., p. AS1] worth
$405 million. He was noted in 1999 by the San Francisco
Examiner as "San Francisco's
biggest landlord," owning
"about 25 percent of the
city's downtown rental property."
[BRAZIL, E., 11-5-99, p.
A4]
Also in San Francisco,
Richard Swig -- winner of
Israel's Golda Meir award
-- founded the posh
Fairmount hotel chain;
he also served as on positions
for the Anti-Defamation
League and the Jewish Community
Federation. By the
1880s, Adolph Sutro, a Jewish
immigrant from Prussia,
alone owned "roughly one-twelfth
of the land in San Francisco."
He also became the mayor
of the city. [NEWITZ, A.,
1-13-99]
In
a March 2000 letter to an
online magazine, famed San
Francisco poet Lawrence
Ferlinghetti singled out
a Jewish real estate developer
who was central in the cultural
destruction of that city:
A
developer from Michigan,
Scott Seligman, who runs
Sterling Bank and
Seligman
Western Enterprises, wants
to gentrify the Mid-Market
zone. Not
to
make the City a better place
but to make his bank account
a little fatter.
Hew
wants a bretter class of
tenant. No more photographers
or poets or
translators
or editors or painters.
Nomore small businesses
serving the City."
[FERLINGHETTI,
3-8-01]
In 1989 the Los
Angeles Times called
Martin Selig "Seattle's
biggest property owner."
He had recently sold Seattle's
tallest building for $354
million. [DIETRICH, B.,
11-20-89, p. D1]
A decade earlier
in Seattle, Forbes
noted that Jack Benaroya
(also Jewish), "for 30 years
built the Seattle area's
largest real estate empire:
8 million commercial square
feet, about 90% industrial,
including 5 business parks."
[FORBES, 10-27-86, p. 290]
Another Jewish real
estate developer, William
Levitt, is credited -- or
blamed - for the creation
of "massive tract developments
of single family homes ...
He shaped the American dream,
a house of one's own for
a small down payment and
an endless mortgage." [KREFETZ,
p. 50] Levitt was instrumental
in the invention of "suburbia":
sprawls of mass-produced
uniform tract houses. Between
1947 and 1951 his company
constructed 17,447 homes
for 75,000 people on Long
Island, known today as Levittown.
He also created another
housing conglomeration --
also called Levittown --
in Pennsylvania. George
Ritzer notes that:
"Levitt and
Sons thought of their building
sites as large factories.
Instead
of having the
product move, as one the
automobile assembly line,
the
Levitt's product,
the emerging house, was
stationary, and it was the
workers who
moved around the building
site ... Said Alfred Levitt,
one
of the sons:
'The same man does the same
thing every day, despite
the
psychologists.
It is boring; it is bad;
but the reward of the green
stuff
seems to alleviate
the boredom of the work."
[RITZER, p. 28]
By 1973, Arthur Cohen
was chairman of Arlen
Realty and Development Corporation,
"a corporation that controlled
some $1.7 billion of U.S.
real estate." [CARRUTH,
E., 1973, p. 184] ... Shopping
centers are the largest
single element of Arlen's
business, and the company
is one of the nation's largest
builders (as well as operators)
of them." [CARRUTH, p. 187]
Cohen and three associates
held 49 percent of the voting
shares in the company.
By 1982,
another Jewish real estate
mogul, Samuel J. Lefrak,
alone owned 55,000 apartments
in New York City and another
30,000 elsewhere, run by
some 350 different companies,
each owned by the Lefrak
family. [KREFETZ, p. 81] By 1982 too, "the great majority of
the New York landlords [were]
Jewish" including the prominent
family names of Uris, Durst,
Tishman, Rudin, Horowitz,
Ravitch, Minskoff, Milstein,
Sol Goldman, and Frederic
Rose, a former President
of the Jewish Philanthropies
of New York. [BAER, p. 195]
Before financial
problems in the late 1960s,
William Zeckendorf was "master,
at one time, of possibly
the greatest of all real
estate empires." [BLACKWELL,
E., 1973, p. 534] In the
early 1990s the Rudins owned
buildings worth $1.5 billion.
Other huge Jewish real estate
empires include [d] those
of Aaron Gural, Leo and
Alexander Bing, the Resnicks,
Fishers, Koeppels, Wiens,
Cohens, and Silversteins.
By 1929 A.E. Lefcourt's
24 buildings (many skyscrapers)
placed him "among the largest
landlords in the city and
squarely in the ranks of
its wealthiest men." [SCHACHTMAN,
p. 117]
Most New York "real
estate barons," confirmed
Tom Schactman in 1991, are
"white and Jewish." [SCHACTMAN,
p. 21]
By the 1920s, "a
survey found that 80 percent
of the speculative builders
in [New York] city were
Jewish although Jews made
up only 40 percent of the
10,000 builders in the metropolitan
area. The [Jewish] immigrants'
domination of the field
worried some; the chairman
of the board of the United
States Realty and Home Improvement
company called the 'foreign
element ... a disturbing
feature in real estate today.'"
[SCHACHTMAN, p. 111] Architecturally,
"even the shopping center
was a [Jewish] émigré contribution,
pioneered by Viennese-born
Victor Gruen ... In Chicago,
[Ludwig] Mies became the
virtual inventor of industrial
design." [HEILBUT, p. 143]
The
premier real estate trader
in the ritzy Hamptons area
of Long Island was (until
he choked on a piece of
steak and died in 1991)
Allan Schneider. Schneider
was both Jewish and homosexual,
although he hid both. He
was, says, Steven Gaines,
"the most powerful broker
in all the Hamptons -- the
'Pasha,' as he was affectionately
called by his staff, with
offices in Southampton,
Bridgehampton, Sag Harbor,
and East Hampton and revenues
approaching $100 million
... [He had] domination
in the Hamptons real estate
market ... He not only substantially
changed the face of the
landscape, but his own life
was in some ways a metaphor
for the new Hamptons: a
stage upon which nouvelle
society could invent itself."
[GAINES, S., 1998, p. 4,
45, 48] How about "the largest
private landowner in all
of East Hampton?" That would
be Evan Frankel, who "held
the deed to more than 1,000
acres of developable land
... at one point he owned
so much land that it was
estimated he paid 50 percent
of all the real estate taxes
in East Hampton. Not coincidentally,
at various times, he held
seats on the town planning
board, the board of directors
of Southampton Hospital,
and the advisory board of
the East Hampton Free Library."
[GAINES, S., 1998, p. 170]
Another
Jewish real estate mogul,
Ben Tobin, once a part owner
of the Empire State Building,
was, like most, "a major
benefactor to Jewish charities."
[NITKIN, p. 6B] Down the street, Jack Weiler's nationwide
holdings equaled 5 million
square feet in New York
alone; 1.5 million more
were owned in California.
"A new community of more
than 2,000 homes and 5,000
residents on the southern
ridge of Jerusalem was named
Kiryat Jack Weiler because
of his support for Israel
and his ability to coax
others to help as well."
[VAN GELDEN, p. 26] Frederic
and Earle Mack's Mack Company,
based in New York and New
Jersey commercial and industrial
development, merged with
another firm in 1997 to
form the Mack-Cali Realty
Corporation "which boasted
a combined market capitalizaiton
of $3.4 billion ... Like
his brother Earle, Frederic
Mack has long shown an abiding
interest in U. S. relations
with Israel ... Mack is
currently on the national
board of the American Israel
Public Affairs Committee,
the nation's largest and
most infoluential pro-Israel
lobby." [MOTHER JONES, 5-3-01]
In
July 2001, a private company
took over control of the
ill-fated World Trade Center.
Silverstein Properties (president:
Larry Silverstein) signed
a 99-year lease to run the
landmark business complex
for $3.2 billion from New
York City's Port Authority
(chairman: Lewis Eisenberg).
[SCT NEWSWIRE, 7-25-01]
The retail section was also
controlled by a Jewish entrepreneur.
As the Jerusalem Post
noted after the 2001 terrorist
attack:
"Australian
businessman Frank Lowy,
who emigrated to Australia
from
Israel in 1952, owns the
99-year lease for the 425,000
square foot retail portion
of the destroyed World Trade
Center. Lowy is the chairman
and founder of
Westfield Holdings,
the manager of Westfield
America Trust, which
has a 57
percent stake in Westfield
America Inc ... Westfield
said today that it has insurance
cover against terrorist
attacks and its earnings
will not be materially affected.
In
a statement to the Australian
Stock Exchange the retail
chain said that 'investment
in the retail component
of the World Trade Center
is fully insured for both
capital
and loss of income,' adding
'the insurance cover includes
acts of terrorism' ...
Today [Lowy] is the second
wealthiest man in Australia
and was recently ranked
as the 209th wealthiest
man in the world by Forbes
magazine. Westfield is the
fourth-largest shopping
mall owner, with operations
in Australia, the US, the
United Kingdom and New Zealand.
Lowy is philanthropically
involved in the
Jewish community in Sydney
as well as Israel, including
sponsoring the Overseas
Students School of Tel Aviv
University which is endowed
in his name and being
associate international
chairman of the Israel Democracy
Institute." [BERGER, S.,
9-12-01]
In
the New York city government
sphere,
"for more than four decades,
without ever holding public
office, Robert Moses
ruled in New York like a
potentate. He spent an estimated
$27 billion on public
works: highways, bridges,
parks, tunnels, beaches,
playgrounds, dams, public
buildings,
and public housing. He was
in large part responsible
for the construction
of the Lincoln Center, the
United Nations, Co-op City,
and the Coliseum. His
most impregnable power base
was the Triborough Bridge
and Tunnel Authority,
where he reigned as chief
executive from 1933 to 1968.
He had helped draft the
legislation
that created the authority
and that at the same time
ensured its existence
in
perpetuity by empowering
it to issue new bonds. The
never-ending stream
of
bridge and tunnel tolls
gave Moses control over
a bond-issuing agency with
exiguous
accountability; during his
tenure the authority, although
a public
agency,
was as autonomous as the
privately governed Metropolitan
Museum.." [MEYER,
K., 1979, p. 93]
Another Jewish mogul,
Aaron Ziegelman, is in "the
controversial business of
buying low-rent buildings
in New York City, renovating
them and selling the apartments
as condominiums. The New
York Times called him
'one of New York's biggest
co-op converters.'" [KLEIN,
A., p. 10]
One of Ziegelman's
pet projects is to reconstruct
an Eastern European village
in Israel; he has also donated
a million dollars to the
Reconstructionist Rabbinical
College in Philadelphia
and a million and a half
to the National Jewish Center
for Learning and Leadership.
Yet another Jewish
real estate mogul is Jerry
Speyer. He married into
the Tishman family, also
Jewish; the family's firm
"Tishman Realty" became
the largest "builder-owner"
in the United States. [TRAUB,
p. 68] Fellow Jewish real
estate developer Bernard
Mendik told the New York
Times Magazine in 1998
that "right now, Jerry [Speyer]
is the Number 1 real-estate
developer in the world."
[TRAUB, p. 62] Today Speyer's
Tishman-Speyer Properties owns 36 million
square feet of building
space, valued at $10.5 billion.
Among other sites Speyer's
firm owns include Manhattan's
Chrysler Building and the
Messerturm in Frankfurt,
Germany (Europe's second
tallest building). He has
served on the boards of
both Columbia University
and the Museum of Modern
Art. Speyer, says journalist
James Traub, "operates in
that elite sphere in which
wealth, public-spiritedness,
and proper table manners
converge to form a colossal
nexus of power, but one
almost invisible to the
outside world." [TRAUB,
p. 64]
In 1995, Business
Week highlighted another
Jewish real estate mogul,
Steve Green:
"Most people
have never head of the 49
year-old real estate maven.
But
Steven
J. Green's empire is growing
fast. His personal holdings
include
120 retail
properties across the United
States, which he estimated
is
worth
$500 million. Through partnerships,
he has a stake in a real
estate
company
in Britain that owns 22
office properties in European
business
centers,
an industrial project in
Eastern Europe, and a retail
development
in Moscow's
Red Square. And he's the
chief executive of Astrum
International Corporation, a $1 billion company that
owns
Samsonite, American Tourister, and Culligan brands."
By 1940,
Albert M. Greenfield's real
estate business in Philadelphia
was the largest in the city.
By age 35 he had "accumulated"
27 building and loan associations
and was known as 'one of
the most influential men
in the city." [SKLARE, p.
284] In early Los Angeles,
Kaspare Cohn "was one of
Southern California's largest
landowners." [GOLDEN, H.,
1973, p. 233] By the 1970s,
noted one Jewish observer,
the (Jewish) Hellman family's
Farmers and Merchant Bank,
"excepting the state, is
the largest property owner
in California." [GOLDEN,
H., 1973, p. 233]
In Chicago, Sam Zell
is "one of the biggest property
owners in the country."
[ALLEN, J. p. C1] Zell built his fortune on slum lording
or, as the Chicago Tribune
puts its, the "buying
of distressed properties
and resurrecting them ...
Zell acquired troubled apartment
buildings in Florida, Reno,
and Las Vegas." [ELSNER,
p. C1] "If you viewed us
as a group," said partner
Burton Kanter, "we were
the biggest landlords in
Reno." [ELSNER, p. C1]
In 1976 Zell and
three associates were indicted
in a tax shelter scheme
over a Reno hotel transaction.
Zell cut a deal with the
government, but his brother-in-law
went to prison. [ALLEN,
J. p. C1]
Chicago-based
Neil Bluhm, president of
JMB Realty, and partner
Judd Malkin, noted Forbes
in 1990:
"are among the
few 1980s property owners
to remain high on the Forbes
Hundred
[richest Americans list].
Each is estimated at over
$770 million,
although
they tell people they are
each worth just under $1
billion."
JMB's reach is far, owning even the
prestigious Century City
office complex -- home to
many in the Hollywood entertainment
world -- in West Los Angeles.
Nearby, in Beverly Hills,
Guilford Glazer oversees
his own $474 million real
estate empire, including
the Del Amo Fashion Mall,
"the largest shopping mall
in the world." [BLUMAY,
C., 1992, p. 415]
Glazer, notes Forbes
magazine, is "active
in Jewish American causes.
[He] built [an] Israeli
community center with buddy
Armand Hammer." [FORBES,
10-12-98] A Beverly Hills
neighbor is Eli Broad, co-founder
of Kaufman & Broad, the Los Angeles
area's "largest home builder."
[GOLDBERG, JJ, 10-22-99] In 1977, Jewish mogul A. Albert Taubman "purchased
77,000 acres of some of
the best land in southern
California between Los Angeles
and San Diego." Taubman,
based in Detroit, "by the
mid-1960s ... was building
shopping centers in California,
the nation's ongoing Mecca
of real estate development
... It was Taubman who continualy
upped the stakes in mall
development, again raising
eyebrows by building them
bigger than anyone else,
placing more stringent demands
on tenants and charging
higher rents for retailers
who set up store under his
roof." [HIGGINS/HOOVER,
5-3-01, p. 4a] A
Holocaust survivor, Frank
Lowy, owns Westfield America, the largest shopping
mall company on the West
Coast, including eight properties
in Los Angeles, eight in
San Diego, and four in Northern
California. In St. Louis,
Missouri, "Lowry has five
malls and is the city's
biggest landlord." In Australia,
Lowy's home base, his "mall
empire ... has blanketed
the continent." The global
asset value of his company's
holdings is $13.2 billion.
[COOLIDGE, 10-19-98]
Also in Chicago,
"Philip Klutznik and his
American Community Builders, and his
later Urban
Investment and Development
Co. went on to build
much of the face of Chicago
over the last half century."
[OLIVER, p. A16] He is largely
responsible for the planned
Chicago suburb of Park Forest
and he owned the downtown
landmark Water Tower Place.
In Washington DC,
yet another Jewish real
estate king, Charles Smith,
controlled "Washington's
greatest real estate fortune."
[HAGGERTY, M. p. F10] His
son Robert, and son-in-law
Robert Kogod today run an
empire of 2,000 employees,
14,000 apartment units (20,000
counting the ones they also
manage), and interests in
54 office buildings. Their
total worth was estimated
by the late 1980s to be
$3-5 billion.
Other area Washington
area Jewish real estate
moguls include the Hafts,
Mort Zuckerman, Albert Abramson,
Ted Lerner, Bernard and
Carol Gewirz, Robert Rosenthal,
Estelle Gelman, Hermen Greenberg,
Abe Pollin, Myer and Adrienne
Arsht Feldman, Joel Meisel
and Barry Cohen, among others.
[REGARDIE'S, p. 64-] As
Barbara Matusow notes about
an earlier Jewish generation
in the nation's capitol:
"Morris Pollin eventually
became a leading builder
and developer in
the area --
the path to wealth for so
many other Jews of humble
origins ...
Abraham Kay parlayed his
earnings from a grocery
store
on Capitol Hill
into vast landholdings in
the suburbs. Morris
Cafritz, the
city's richest developer,
used to hawk newspapers...
Nearly all the
other first generation success
stories -- car dealer
Joe Cherner,
Giant Food's patriarch Nehemiah
Cohen, Macke
Vending's Hyman
Goldberg, lumber merchant
Isadore Turover --
also had major
holdings in real estate."
[MATUSOW, B., MAY 2000,
In Houston, Jewish
real estate mogul Jerry
Moore is worth over $400
million, owning over 140
shopping centers. Forbes
noted that he bought
"shabby,
low-profit but promising
strip centers and turn[ed]
them
into
born-again cash machines
... Moore lives with his
wife in an
authentic
18th-century, 40-room French
chateau (transported from
France
and reassembled in Houston's
ritzy Memorial section).
He
owns
22 Ferraris, 14 Rolls Royces,
and over 200 well-restored
antique
Dusenbergs,
Packards, and other vehicles."
[FIELD, p. 32]
Elsewhere in Houston,
David Mincberg owns "one
of the largest apartment
firms in the city." [HOUSTON
CHRONICLE, 1998] He is also
chairman of the Harris County
Democratic Party and president
of the Jewish Federation
of Greater Houston.
Also in Texas, based
in Dallas, the Centex
real estate company "is
one of the nation's largest
home builders, with operations
in 53 markets in 19 states."
[NEW YORK TIMES, 9-3-98]
Its CEO is also Jewish,
Laurence Hirsch.
In Boston, "the
young professionals who
began favoring Boston as
a place to live around the
time of the Vietnam War
are ensconced in their lairs,
many of them either built
or financed by [Mark] Goldweitz."
[ROBINSON, p. 61] In 2000,
Jerome Rappaport sold his
massive Charles River Park
development -- apartments
and condos -- for $300 million.
[Van Voorhis, S., 2-14-00]
Other Jewish real estate
moguls in Boston include
"the Krupp brothers, Philip
and William, who made a
killing in real estate,"
as well as Stephen Karp,
Julian Cohen, Bruce Beal,
Steve Fishman, Ron Drucker,
Dick Friedman, Alan Leventhal,
and Edwin Sidman, among
others. [BOSTON MAGAZINE]
Owner of properties throughout
New England, Holocaust survivor
Simon Konover -- owner of
over 11 million square feet
of real estate -- "is a
staunch supporter of Jewish
charities." [CHAINSTORE,
p. 92] Richard Penzer has
a "real estate empire" in
Pittsburgh; in Chicago,
by 1988 William Adler had
developed over 100 suburban
and industrial properties
and thousands of homes.
In Los Angeles,
by 1992 Jona Goldrich and
Abraham Lurie alone controlled
25% (worth $250 million)
of the luxurious Marina
Del Rey beach area. "For
years," notes the Los
Angeles Times, "Goldrich
has been active in Jewish
affairs." [RABIN, J., p.
B1] Goldrich has been "a
major builder of residential
and commercial projects
throughout California" and
a "major player" in the
$400 million Channel Gateway
project near Marina Del
Rey. In 1991 he was awarded
a controversial contract
by the Los Angeles County
to control over 18 acres
of prime Marina Del Rey
waterfront for the next
70 years. "Mark Nathanson
[also Jewish], a Beverly
Hills real estate broker
and a member of the California
Coastal Commission," noted
the Los Angeles Times,
"was a leading supporter
of the lease extension [to
Goldrich] when the five-member
Small Craft Harbor Commission
met last week." "Nathanson,"
observed the Times,
"is the target of a federal
political corruption investigation
in Sacramento." [RABIN,
J., 12-23-91, p. B1] For
Abraham Lurie's part, he
was once even a business
partner with the brother-in-law
of Saudi Arabia's King Fahd.
In 1992, before economic
problems, Lurie was described
as Marina Del Rey's "biggest
developer." [RABIN, J.,
7-29-92, p. B1]
In Miami, Jewish real
estate moguls include Craig
Robins. As one journalist
notes:
"[Robins] is
Miami's most celebrated
purchaser and rehabber of
dilapidated
buildings ... A few in Miami
Beach gripe that Robins'
rep and political
clout have made him and
[his company called]
Dacra inordinately influential in the
city, greasing the skids
for any
proposed project
that has his name on it."
Robins' partners include
his brother Scott and New
York-based developer Tony
Goldman. [KISSELL, T., 6-15-99]
Even in Mormon-dominated
Utah, John Price is the
(Jewish) chairman and CEO
of JP Realty, "among the top commercial
real estate developers in
the Intermountain West,
owning and managing properties
in Utah and nine surrounding
states." These holdings
include 12 enclosed shopping
malls, other shopping centers
and various commercial and
industry buildings. [KNUDSON,
M., 3-23, 97] In Denver,
Sally Barry made local news
when she fought prominent
real estate developer Jordan
Perlmutter's plans that
would obscure beautiful
views of the Rocky Mountains
from popular Robert Clement
Park. [GREEN, C., 2-22-95,
p., B7] Also in Denver,
Israeli-raised Shaul Baruch,
son of a rabbi, was noted
in 1995 as a "wealthy land
developer" who had recently
purchased "443 acres of
prime dirt near Denver International
Airport." [REBCHOOK, J.,
12-5-95, p. A47]
In Omaha, Nebraska, as an
addenda to the real estate
world, Phil and Harley Schrager
own the Pacesetter Corporation, the "largest
independent, direct-seller
and manufacturer of residential
building and improvement
products in the United States."
[JEWISH PRESS, 3-31-2000,
p. 1]
In Canada, the
Reichmann family has an
international real estate
empire and, by the 1980s,
before financial troubles,
were reputed to be "one
of the wealthiest families
in the world." [BUCHINSKY,
p. 4]
The Reichmanns owned
the largest real estate
empire on earth, as well
as the world's largest newsprint
producer (Albitibi-Price), plus various other
holdings. The former Deputy
Minister of Finance for
Canada, Marshall Cohen,
directed the large
Olympia and York division
of the Reichmann sprawl.
"The Reichmann's main business
vehicle, Olympia
and York Development,"
notes Anthony Bianco, "was
the greatest property development
company in Western history."
[BIANCO, p. xv] "At the
peak of their success ...
the Reichmann's donated
$60 million annually to
[Jewish] Orthodox institutions
worldwide." [ATLAS, p. 264]
The Jewish
Reichmann and Bronfman
families were instrumental
in building New York's tallest
landmark, the World Trade
Center, and in the late
1970s the Reichmanns had
major downtown development
projects in ten American
cities. [BIANCO, p. 368]
"In Florida, Olympia and York generally invested
along with the Shapiro family."
[BIANCO, p. 399]
"Seagrams [owned
by the Montreal-based Bronfman
family] are not only the
largest liquor empire in
the world, but the largest
private land-owners in Canada."
[BERMANT, C., 1977, p. 68]
Also from Montreal, Maxwell
Cummings' real estate company
has owned land and buildings
across North America. In
1948 he built an apartment
complex "which was the largest
privately owned housing
development in Canada ...
Throughout his life, Cummings
has played an important
role in the Jewish community."
[BEAUDIN, p. A4] Cummings,
who died in 2001, was "a
leading developer of low-cost
housing in Canada." [EISENTHAL,
B., 5-24-01] An Orthodox
Jew from Toronto, real estate
baron Stephen Mernick, even
bought (for $139 million)
the 500-acre PTL Christian
theme park in North Carolina
(after the sex scandal that
swept Jim and Tammy Bakker
into ruins). [DOLPHIN, p
38]
Also in Canada, Jewish
mogul Peter Munk, while
heading "one of the world's
most valuable gold mining
companies, Barrick
Gold," also controls
"Toronto's landmark CN Tower,
lots of office space in
New York, and what is described
rather coyly as effective
ownership of the Sears Tower
in Chicago." [FINANCIAL
TIMES, 6-30-98, p. 21]
In 2000, Jacob Ghermezian
died. A Jew from Iran, he
"built a real estate empire
in Canada." [KIRSCHNER,
S., 9-14-2000, p. 11]
Even in a place like
Sacramento, California,
Mort Friedman "is prominent
in two of the most public
arenas in town, law and
development." [DELSOHN,
p. A1] Both a lawyer and a real estate developer
(including Sacramento's
Market Square mall), his
personal fortune is estimated
to be about $100 million.
Friedman has worked "for
improved U.S.-Israeli relations,"
says the Sacramento Bee,
"He lobbied Congress and
met with Israeli leaders
as an officer of the American
Israel Public Affairs Committee."
[DELSOHN, p. A1]
In 1989,
a roomful of such Jewish
real estate barons and assorted
slum lords gathered to hear
the Jewish New York State
Attorney General, Robert
Abrams, speak at the "Greater
New York Real Estate and
Construction Division of
the State of Israel Bonds."
Real estate mogul Sheldon
Solow received the "Israel
Peace Medal." Abrams, noted
a news wire dispatch, "as
a public official and even
before that, ... has been
a strong voice on behalf
of Jewish causes ... [and
an] ardent champion of the
state of Israel ... While
he was borough president,
he successfully persuaded
the New York City Board
of Education to incorporate
Jewish Heritage Week into
the curriculum of public
schools." [PR NEWSWIRE,
11-3-89] The chair of the
Real Estate Board of New
York at the time (1988)
was also Jewish: Larry Silverstein.
Such men no doubt included
David Steiner, head of Steiner
Equities Group, "a real
estate concern which oversees
millions of square feet
of commercial and industrial
property from its New Jersey
headquarters." Steiner is
a former president of AIPAC,
the foremost lobbying agency
for Israel in America. [MOTHER
JONES, 3-5-01]
In Europe, in 1997,
the Deutche Presse Agence
wire service noted that
"Berlin's Jewish community
is currently in turmoil,
its standing in the city
tarnished by reports of
dubious real estate dealing
and political in-fighting
among some of its members."
[FREEMAN, C.] Jewish entrepreneurs
were noted to have even
swindled Holocaust survivors.
"Our image is tarnished
in the public eye by all
the talk of corruption and
scandal," the wire service
was told at the Jewish Community
Center of Berlin."
"Recently," noted
the Agentur, "a [Jewish
Community Center leader's]
husband was investigated
by the police, reputedly
for forcing a woman from
Riga int | | |